← Back to House of Commons Debates
Israel and Gaza: Ceasefire
19 May 2021
Lead MP
James Cleverly
Debate Type
Ministerial Statement
Tags
Foreign Affairs
Other Contributors: 31
At a Glance
James Cleverly raised concerns about israel and gaza: ceasefire in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Government Statement
Mr James Cleverly, Minister of State at the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, made a statement expressing condolences to families affected by violence in Israel and Palestine. He outlined the UK's diplomatic efforts towards an immediate ceasefire and a peaceful resolution, including working closely with mediators such as Egypt and Qatar, supporting US efforts, engaging regional partners, and participating actively in UN Security Council meetings. The Minister emphasised that the UK condemns rocket attacks by Hamas and urges all parties to respect international humanitarian law and ensure proportionality in their actions. He also reiterated the UK's commitment against Israeli settlement expansion and called for a two-state solution.
Question
Expressed grave concern over civilian casualties, condemned both rocket attacks by Hamas and airstrikes by Israel. Inquired about UK diplomatic efforts for an immediate ceasefire and humanitarian aid provision to Gaza. Urged the Government to urgently restart a peace process that upholds international law and ends illegal occupation.
Minister reply
Acknowledged the importance of ongoing diplomatic efforts including visible work through UN institutions and discreet engagement with regional partners. Confirmed the UK's commitment to an immediate ceasefire and emphasised the need for negotiated political solutions.
Question
Welcomed Minister’s support for Israel’s right to defend its citizens, asked whether the Government would consider proscribing Hamas as a whole alongside Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.
Minister reply
Confirmed that military wing of Hamas is already recognised internationally as a terrorist organisation. Stated UK Government's no-contact policy with Hamas and emphasised commitment to negotiated political solutions rather than military means.
Chris Law
SNP
Dundee Central
Question
Called for immediate ceasefire, questioned whether the UK would recognise Palestine as a nation state. Raised concerns about potential war crimes and human rights law violations by both sides. Inquired about pressures to investigate breaches and suspending arms exports to Israel.
Minister reply
Urged against equating legitimate government of Israel with terrorist organisation Hamas. Emphasised the UK’s call for adherence to international humanitarian law, minimisation of civilian casualties, and pursuit of a two-state solution through diplomatic engagement.
Question
Reports indicate that at least 500 Hamas rockets—one in seven of the total number fired—have exploded within Gaza, and a Palestinian NGO has confirmed that eight Palestinians were killed by a short-falling rocket last week. Does my right hon. Friend agree that Hamas's rocket fire not only endangers Israelis but also causes grave harm to ordinary Gazans and must be condemned? Also, does he acknowledge the existential threats Israel faces from Hamas and Hezbollah, funded and backed by Iran, and argue against moral equivalence between democratic Israel and these terrorist organisations?
Minister reply
The UK maintains good relations with both the Government of Israel and the Palestinian Authority. I urge everyone to recognise that Hamas is no friend of the Palestinian people as its military wing is recognised as a terrorist organisation. The UK will work with leadership from both sides, alongside international partners, for peace. Nobody wants to see further fatalities.
Layla Moran
Lib Dem
Oxford West and Abingdon
Question
The number of Palestinian children who have died in Gaza has risen from 14 to 63 since last week. My heart is shattered now, and we need a ceasefire. Why did the UK not take the lead on this issue as France did with its UN resolution? If committed to lasting peace, why do they not recognise Palestine?
Minister reply
I understand the hon. Lady’s passion for the Palestinian people. The UK works closely with international partners at the United Nations and elsewhere to bring about peace. We are focused on ending violence immediately so that we can work towards a two-state solution.
Question
Welcoming the commitment to a two-state solution, will he update the House on the extent to which the UK is using its presidency of the G7 to help broker international consensus for a ceasefire?
Minister reply
We are working with all diplomatic contacts and leverage available. We work closely with the United Nations but also seek out other organisations that can contribute positively towards peace. The UK leaves no stone unturned in efforts to bring about an end to this conflict.
Rupa Huq
Lab
Ealing Central and Acton
Question
With the destruction of schools, hospitals, and cultural centres, and the cutting of aid contributions internationally, does he agree that although UK policy is against illegal settlements and for a two-state solution, our lack of proactivity sometimes makes it look as if we do not really mean it? Netanyahu has been able to cement his position due to this.
Minister reply
We continue to work with the Governments elected by the Israeli people. While recognition of Palestine is important, the focus now must be on ending the current conflict and working towards a sustainable two-state solution.
Question
Given that Iran’s role in this conflict undermines peace and stability throughout the middle east via its proxy terror group allies, what assurances can my right hon. Friend give today that discussions on resuscitating the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action agreement will not repeat past mistakes?
Minister reply
My right hon. Friend raises a crucial point. We recognise that in our desire to prevent Iran acquiring nuclear weapons we cannot ignore its destabilising activities. This will remain one of our priorities and is regularly raised with interlocuters in the region.
Richard Burgon
Lab
Leeds East
Question
How many more Palestinian children have to be killed, homes reduced to rubble, schools and hospitals bombed before action necessary to force Israel to stop its war on Palestinians is taken? Surely it's time for UK weapons sales to Israel to be stopped and sanctions applied.
Minister reply
Israel’s actions were in response to indiscriminate rocket attacks from a recognised terrorist organisation. While the issue of recognition is important, now is about ending this conflict immediately.
Question
Given our history and legacy, could Britain lean into this more by calling for a US-led ceasefire? Palestinian elections have not taken place in over 16 years, and Hamas has no interest in working with Fatah or Israelis. Could neighbouring Muslim countries be invited to help encourage Palestinians to hold fresh elections?
Minister reply
My right hon. Friend raises important points. The UK supports elections for the Palestinian Authority which are overdue. We urge the Palestinian people to choose a leadership respected internationally and able to negotiate with international partners.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Question
Hamas is trying to make the Palestinian Authority and Mahmoud Abbas redundant, presenting itself as the ultimate defender of Jerusalem and al-Aqsa. Given our history in this country, will the Minister tell Hamas that the British Government will never do business with terrorists?
Minister reply
The military wing of Hamas is recognised as a terrorist organisation. The future of the Palestinian people should lie in the hands of those able to negotiate on the international stage and Hamas is not in such a position.
Question
Welcoming the Prime Minister’s call for both sides to step back from the brink, does my right hon. Friend agree that continued escalation will only lead to further violence and more deaths? Both sides need to urgently down their arms.
Minister reply
My hon. Friend makes a correct point. The images of fatalities and injuries among Israelis and Palestinians are heartbreaking. We continue to work with international partners towards peace and an ultimate two-state solution.
Jeremy Corbyn
Ind
Islington North
Question
Asked about the nature of Britain’s military relationship with Israel, including whether munitions and drone equipment sold to or by Britain have been used in attacks on Gaza and the West Bank. Also questioned the occupied territories' suffering.
Minister reply
Stated that UK has a robust arms export licensing regime; UK takes its arms export responsibilities seriously; Israel is responding to rockets from an organisation closely associated with Iran.
Question
Asked if the Minister is working with international counterparts to calm tensions and ensure peace, and to protect the Abraham accords.
Minister reply
Confirmed he had productive conversations about peace with Arab nations including Palestinian representatives; all parties share desire for quick peace.
Diane Abbott
Ind
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Question
Asked if the Minister recognises that long-term solutions include UK demanding end to forced evictions of Palestinians, respecting sacred sites, halting new settlements, adhering to international law, and recognising Palestine as a state.
Minister reply
Reiterated opposition to evictions, demolitions, and settlements; stated recognition of Palestine would come when conducive to peace effort.
Andrew Murrison
Con
South West Wiltshire
Question
Asked if Iran's involvement is a key factor in the lack of peace, suggesting Iran must be less disruptive.
Minister reply
Encourages Iran to be less disruptive; continues working towards two-state solution.
Question
Asked about plans for long-term solutions after ceasefire in Gaza, including support for healthcare and humanitarian aid.
Minister reply
Acknowledged damage to medical facilities; seeks end to conflict so humanitarian aid can reach those who need it.
Question
Asked if moderate Palestinians should be supported and championed in addition to condemning Hamas.
Minister reply
Agreed that support for moderate Palestinians is important; seeks peace through international cooperation.
Chris Bryant
Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Question
Asked if it's unhelpful to take sides in the conflict, suggesting humanity should be the focus.
Minister reply
Agreed that focusing on peace and coexistence is wise; seeks end to conflict for both Palestinians and Israelis.
Andrew Slaughter
Lab
Hammersmith and Chiswick
Question
Asked about actual steps the Government will take to tackle causes of violence, beyond existing policies.
Minister reply
Acknowledged tensions have persisted for decades; seeks sustainable future through international cooperation.
Question
Asked if the Minister agrees that Hamas must be condemned and weakened, and co-existence projects supported.
Minister reply
Agreed on importance of supporting peace efforts by Palestinians and Israelis; praised effectiveness of Israeli air defence systems.
Munira Wilson
Lib Dem
Twickenham
Question
I am utterly horrified by the scenes unfolding in Gaza, as are hundreds of my constituents who have contacted me to express their concerns. The UK Government are absolutely right to condemn Hamas’s rocket attacks, but they must also condemn in much stronger terms the completely disproportionate response from the Israeli Government, which has resulted in the loss of hundreds of civilian lives, including at least 63 children, coming on the back of sustained breaches of international law for many years. So I ask again: given the UK’s historic responsibility in the region, will the Minister urgently intensify and accelerate efforts with international partners to broker an immediate ceasefire by both sides, and will he suspend arms exports to Israel?
Minister reply
I have already made clear our desire to see an immediate end to the hostilities, a permanent ceasefire and a negotiated settlement between the Palestinians and the Israelis. We have also urged that, in their response to rocket attacks from within civilian infrastructure in Gaza, the Israelis exercise all caution to minimise civilian casualties. That will remain the UK Government’s position on this issue.
Greg Smith
Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
Question
Yesterday, Israel facilitated dozens of trucks filled with humanitarian aid, including field hospitals and covid vaccines, to enter Gaza, yet Hamas deliberately fired repeat barrages of mortars at the Israeli crossing terminal, injuring an Israel Defence Forces soldier involved in the aid transfer and killing two foreign workers nearby. Will my right hon. Friend join me in condemning that appalling incident, which shows, as he stated earlier, that the actions of Hamas are categorically not in the interests of Palestinian people?
Minister reply
My hon. Friend makes an incredibly important point. As I said in my initial response, the targeting of civilians is unacceptable, and the specific targeting of humanitarian access routes particularly so. I have urged Hamas and other terrorist organisations to cease their targeting of humanitarian access routes, so that our support and the support of others in the international community can get to the people who need it.
Liam Byrne
Lab
Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North
Question
We heard the Minister’s statement of policy; we just do not understand the strategy for advancing it. He has to realise, like the rest of us, that there is no peace without justice. The way to disarm Hamas, to make progress towards peace and to ensure genuine calm and de-escalation can only be through the full realisation of Palestinian rights and the end of systematic discrimination against Palestinians in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. It is vital that the UK uses its influence with the United States to insist on a ceasefire. It is vital that the UK Government fully support the International Criminal Court investigation into all alleged war crimes, no matter which party stands accused, including those who are launching appalling rockets and those launching airstrikes. It is vital that we suspend the sale of arms to Israel until we know the outcomes of these prosecutions. Crucially, it is vital that the UK understands that the hope of peace is disappearing because people no longer believe that a two-state solution is possible. That is why we have to act now to sustain hope among Palestinians by ensuring recognition of the state of Palestine.
Minister reply
I recognise the passion with which the right hon. Gentleman speaks, but there can be no legitimisation of indiscriminate rocket attacks against civilian targets from within civilian infrastructure by an internationally recognised terrorist organisation.
Mark Harper
Con
Question
I thank the Minister for his robust support on behalf of the British Government for Israel’s right to defend itself from attack by a proscribed terrorist organisation. Listening to what he said about the prospects for peace, it is clear that Hamas has no interest in dialogue and moving towards peace. What can we do to strengthen the Palestinian Authority, which is a credible partner for peace, and to reduce the influence of Iran, which is trying to strengthen the hand of those who are Israel’s enemies and who do not wish to see peace for the Palestinians?
Minister reply
My right hon. Friend makes an incredibly important point. The Palestinian people have many friends and allies in the international community and they have people within their own leadership who are determined to bring about peace and see a peaceful two-state solution. We should find ways of strengthening their voices and their hands and work with them in pursuit of a two-state solution.
Tan Dhesi
Lab
Slough
Question
The nub of this issue, having visited both Israel and Palestine, is a colonial-era mindset of a gradual land grab: the forcible eviction of people from their homes; the building of illegal settlements; the extreme and shameless violation of human rights and international law; and the sheer suppression and humiliation of an entire nation. At this point in time, however, the efforts of the international community should be focused on securing an immediate end to the bloodshed and hostility. So can the Minister explain: where is the logjam and exactly how much aid have we managed to get through to the inhumanely blockaded Gaza?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman makes the important point that the priority at the moment is twofold: an immediate end to the conflict and the immediate access of humanitarian aid. The UK remains one of the most generous donors of humanitarian support to the Palestinian people and we are very proud of that fact.
Bob Blackman
Con
Harrow East
Question
Reports emerged yesterday that Hamas had launched a torpedo at Israel’s natural gas field in the Mediterranean and that an armed unmanned aerial vehicle caused an explosion at Israel’s Ashkelon power station. Does my right hon. Friend agree that Hamas’s ability to acquire these non-conventional weapons is a very worrying development? Will he join me in condemning Hamas for targeting energy infrastructure that will disrupt energy supplies not only in Israel, but in Gaza?
Minister reply
I am not able to confirm the reports to which my hon. Friend referred, but I reinforce the points that I made about the need for Iran not to be a destabilising influence in the region, for Hamas to step back from this conflict and for both sides to step back and pursue peace so that we can work to a negotiated, permanent two-state solution to the region.
Question
I associate myself and my party with the Minister’s opening words about the wholly unacceptable deaths and casualties, particularly of children. Self-evidently, the first step to peace is to stop the violence. President Biden has expressed support for the ceasefire, according to press reports. Can the Minister reassure me that all relevant international partners are actively working for an immediate ceasefire as a prelude to a substantial international attempt to secure a permanent and just solution?
Minister reply
I can assure the hon. Gentleman that everyone I have spoken to in the international community is absolutely focused on bringing about an end to this conflict and a ceasefire.
Bury South
Question
Of Hamas’s many deplorable aspects, its cynical locating of military infrastructure within densely populated civilian areas is perhaps the worst. This was confirmed again yesterday, as Hamas was found to be launching rockets close to a school. Will my right hon. Friend join me in condemning this double war crime?
Minister reply
My hon. Friend makes an incredibly important point. The location of military activities within civilian infrastructure is completely unacceptable and demonstrates a disturbing attitude towards the lives of the Palestinians that the leadership of Hamas claim to be defending.
Caroline Lucas
Green
Brighton Pavilion
Question
There are many underlying reasons for this most intractable of conflicts, most notably 54 years of occupation of Palestine and 14 years of the blockade of the Gaza Strip, but the most recent violence and devastating damage and loss of life has been inflamed by Israeli violations of the fourth Geneva convention in occupied east Jerusalem and the rest of the west bank. While I welcome the Government’s long-term focus on peace and the two-state solution, can the Minister tell us specifically what consequences the UK is advocating to the international community to deal with Israel’s illegal actions? What steps is he taking, beyond raising it in bilateral talks with Israeli Ministers, to ensure the end of all settlement building and the cancellation of all forcible evictions and demolitions in Sheikh Jarrah and elsewhere?
Minister reply
The hon. Lady implies that bilateral conversations with partners are somehow invalid, but that is how diplomacy is done. Speaking with our friends and partners around the world and in the region is how we bring about positive change.
Shadow Comment
Wayne David
Shadow Comment
Mr Wayne David, representing the Opposition, expressed grave concern over the loss of life due to ongoing conflict between Hamas and Israel, condemning both rocket attacks and airstrikes. He inquired about specific diplomatic actions taken by the UK Government to secure a ceasefire and provide humanitarian aid to Gaza. The shadow minister urged the Government to actively engage in peace processes that uphold international law and end illegal occupation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.