← Back to House of Commons Debates
Yemen: Aid Funding
02 March 2021
Lead MP
James Cleverly
Debate Type
Ministerial Statement
Tags
Foreign Affairs
Other Contributors: 21
At a Glance
James Cleverly raised concerns about yemen: aid funding in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Government Statement
The Minister James Cleverly announced that the UK will provide at least £87 million in aid to Yemen over the course of financial year 2021-22, making their total contribution since the conflict began exceed £1 billion. This new pledge aims to feed an additional 240,000 of the most vulnerable Yemenis every month and support 400 health clinics. It also includes clean water provision for 1.6 million people and one-off cash support to 1.5 million poorest households in Yemen. Cleverly emphasised that improving humanitarian circumstances is a priority while condemning Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia and reinforcing the UK's diplomatic role in supporting UN peace efforts.
Andrew Mitchell
Con
Sutton Coldfield
Question
The Minister is a decent fellow who will not have enjoyed what he announced yesterday. The United Nations Secretary-General stated that cutting aid for Yemen is akin to delivering a death sentence, especially with cuts by over 50%. Sir Mark Lowcock warned of millions of children starving slowly and agonisingly due to reduced aid. Mitchell questioned the rationale behind such a cut given that Britain remains one of the wealthiest countries in the world.
Minister reply
Minister Cleverly thanked Andrew Mitchell for his passion, reminding the House that while £87 million represents the minimum commitment, previous years' distributions have always exceeded initial pledges. He emphasised that the UK will remain one of the largest donors to Yemen and among the most generous in official development assistance.
Preet Kaur Gill
Lab Co-op
Birmingham Edgbaston
Question
The Government’s announcement at a high pledging conference discarded the British people's proud history of supporting those in need. Cutting aid is a death sentence that this Government have chosen to make, so will the Minister take this opportunity to apologise? Will he stop all UK arms sales to Saudi Arabia and publish a full list of cuts made in 2020 and to be made in 2021 by the end of the week?
Minister reply
Our aid budget remains £10 billion, representing one of the largest aid budgets globally. The cut from 0.7% to 0.5% is a temporary reduction due to unprecedented economic circumstances. Diplomatic efforts continue to address the conflict in Yemen and provide humanitarian support.
Thomas Tugendhat
Con
Tonbridge
Question
Does the Minister agree that UK’s position leaves a large gap for the world's poorest to suffer, and has he reached out to Gulf countries and Iran to help fill this gap?
Minister reply
The UK remains one of the largest donors. We lobby international communities but do not currently have bilateral relations with Iran to make credible requests.
Chris Law
SNP
Dundee Central
Question
Is the Minister’s conscience still clear regarding continuing arms sales to Saudi Arabia after cutting humanitarian aid by 50%? What is this Government’s response going to be?
Minister reply
The UK remains one of the largest donors and supports feeding children, providing clean water, medical assistance. We condemn Houthi attacks.
Craig Whittaker
Con
Not specified
Question
Does the Minister agree that progress can be made only through international cooperation with everyone playing their part to solve the crisis?
Minister reply
Money alone is not enough; diplomatic efforts and development efforts must go hand-in-hand. We continue to work on both fronts.
Sarah Champion
Lab
Rotherham
Question
What is the reason behind cutting aid to Yemen by 60%, and what impact assessment has been made of these cuts?
Minister reply
The cut represents a temporary reduction due to economic circumstances. The UK will continue its work on the international sphere addressing humanitarian issues while aiming for a sustainable peace solution.
Bury South
Question
Our £214 million-worth of aid funding for Yemen this year will support at least 500,000 vulnerable people each month to help them buy food and household essentials, treat 55,000 children for malnutrition, and provide 1 million people with improved water supply and basic sanitation. Will my right hon Friend reassure the House that he is stressing to the conflict parties that it is essential that they allow this aid to reach the areas that it is intended to help? Does he agree that, given these figures, now is not the time to be reducing aid to those whom we supply in Yemen who are most in need?
Minister reply
I recognise the point that my hon Friend makes about the totality of our aid spending and my colleagues will have heard that. We also very much support his point about ensuring that the aid gets to the people who need it and that we maintain humanitarian corridors. That is why we have spoken with the Houthis and others about ensuring that those humanitarian corridors are maintained.
Jeremy Corbyn
Ind
Islington North
Question
The crisis in Yemen is wholly human made. Thousands have died as a result of the war, thousands of children have lost homes and lost schools, and poverty and starvation are the order of the day. Britain’s record in this is appalling. Throughout this whole conflict, we have armed Saudi Arabia knowing full well that those missiles are killing people in Yemen, and at the same time claiming to be the harbingers of peace by organising a resolution at the United Nations. Will the Minister make it very clear that all arms sales to Saudi Arabia will stop and that Britain will be a determined partner in trying to bring about a peace process through a ceasefire as quickly as possible and to build good relations with all countries in the region? Too many people have died. The conflict has gone on too long and it simply has to stop. We should be a party to ending the war, not promoting the war.
Minister reply
The right hon Gentleman speaks with an authoritative voice, particularly on Iran. Perhaps if he would also call upon the Iranian regime to no longer give lethal support to the Houthis, that might be a big step in the right direction to bring about sustainable peace in Yemen.
David Davis
Con
Goole and Pocklington
Question
There is a strong convention that before a Government undertake a policy that puts lives at risk, they get prior approval from this House. We cannot make a 50% cut in this budget without cutting into crisis and healthcare support, thereby putting at least 100,000 children’s lives at risk. Will my right hon Friend guarantee that before the Budget votes are held next week we can have a written statement giving a breakdown of the cuts made this year in the aid budget and undertaking that no more cuts will be undertaken unless and until this House approves it?
Minister reply
I am not completely sure that the convention my right hon Friend refers to is relevant in this situation. As the Foreign Secretary has said before, we are looking very carefully at what is required by law. The legislation envisaged that the 0.7% target may not be met in a particular year in the light of economic and fiscal circumstances.
Layla Moran
Lib Dem
Oxford West and Abingdon
Question
The Government’s appalling decision to cut aid to Yemen has been described as “a death sentence” by the UN Secretary-General, and he is right. This enormous cut, in a year when 400,000 children under five might starve to death, is not only heartless but, just like the cut to the 0.7%, damages the UK’s international reputation, and they are doing this just weeks after announcing £1.36 billion in new arms sales to Saudi Arabia—the exact opposite of what the United States is doing. Is this what we can now expect—the UK Government shrinking away from their commitments, leaving other, more compassionate countries to pick up the slack?
Minister reply
The hon Lady implies that expenditure is the only appropriate measure for compassion. If that is the case, she should recognise that the UK is one of the most generous ODA-donating countries in the world, in both absolute terms and relative terms.
Question
The legislation allows the Government to miss the 0.7% target by accident or in an emergency, but not to plan to miss it for an indefinite number of years ahead. Can my right hon Friend give a commitment today that further cuts will not be made until the necessary legislation promised to this House by Ministers who announced this policy has been put to a vote so that this House can express a view?
Minister reply
I hear what my right hon Friend says. The Foreign Secretary, as I said, is looking carefully at the requirements of the legislation. I can assure my right hon Friend, from this position at the Dispatch Box, that the Government are well able to listen to the mood of the House without the need for legislation in this Session.
Hilary Benn
Lab
Leeds South
Question
The Minister referred to the humanitarian aid that the UK has already given to Yemen, which we recognise, but I am afraid he has failed today to explain why the Government have now decided to cut that contribution by more than half. Doing the right thing in the past is not a justification for doing the wrong thing now. Yesterday, a Yemeni aid worker co-ordinating food aid distribution, said this: “Children are dying every day here. It is not a moral decision to abandon Yemen.” Why have the Government done this when for example Germany, which is also facing the same unprecedented economic situation—to use his own words—has managed to pledge twice as much as the United Kingdom?
Minister reply
Different countries at yesterday’s pledging events put forward their pledges. Some increased their pledges; some reduced their pledges. Each country is facing its own economic challenges. The UK remains, despite the unprecedented economic circumstances we face, one of the largest donors both in general terms and in terms of humanitarian support for Yemen.
Question
The Minister started his remarks by saying that money matters. Yes it does, but what this cut represents is a cut to projects, a cut to aid and a cut to assistance that will put lives in jeopardy. If the Government are so reassured by their position, then I suggest that they bring a vote to the House on this issue and they can truly gauge the strength of feeling. We have a moral duty to lead on this issue and I hope he will consider bringing a vote before it is too late.
Minister reply
As I said previously, the Foreign Secretary is looking at the legal requirements around the situation. I completely understand my hon Friend’s passion, but I remind him and the House that we remain one of the largest donors in this humanitarian crisis.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Question
According to the report published yesterday by the all-party group for international freedom of religion or belief, the last remaining Jewish communities in Yemen were ordered to leave in 2020 and the Yemeni Christian community, which once numbered some 41,000, has now shrunk to just a few thousand. Moreover, the Yemeni Baha’i community faced increased persecution at the hands of Houthi authorities last year. Will the Minister share his views on how aid spending in Yemen can be better used to support religious and belief minority groups in Yemen?
Minister reply
I thank the hon Gentleman for his question. The UK provides secondees to the office of Martin Griffiths, the UN special representative. A number of those secondees focus specifically on broad engagement with minorities within the peace process.
Question
As chair of the all-party group for Yemen, yesterday I spoke to some very brave women from within Marib, which is under long-term siege from the Houthis. They told me that most of the Houthi forces are young men and teenage boys recruited from the most impoverished parts of Yemen. They also told me that Marib is now hosting over 2 million displaced people across 144 camps. Many children are not just suffering from famine and disease; they have been deeply traumatised after having been driven out by the Houthis. They all rely on generous UK aid and the example it sets to other countries who need to step up in the humanitarian aid effort and the subsequent reconstruction. How can indicating a cut in UK aid at this crucial time do anything but prolong this terrible conflict?
Minister reply
The situation my hon Friend describes in Marib is deeply concerning. We have called on the Houthis to end their assault. Marib has become the temporary home for many internally displaced people, and the situation there is dire.
Question
No matter how much the Minister attempts to hide behind how much the UK gives, it will not disguise the impact that this brutal 60% cut will have on the life chances of Yemenis. Save the Children says that already 400,000 children under the age of five are at risk of starving to death this year, so I ask the Minister: how many deaths are he and this Tory Government prepared to have on their conscience, because they certainly do not act in my name?
Minister reply
The UK has consistently been one of the largest donors to the humanitarian appeal, and our money is keeping people alive. We are very proud of that fact. The economic circumstances we are currently living through have meant that we have to temporarily reduce the amount of money we are spending in overseas development assistance.
Tobias Ellwood
Con
Not Specified
Question
Yemen remains a significant international security concern, with more terrorist attacks organised from there than anywhere else in the world. With the Biden Administration rewriting their foreign policy towards Yemen, Tobias Ellwood questions whether this presents an opportunity for the UK to end the civil war and improve its strategy, including cutting arms exports and being ready to lead peacekeeping forces as required by the UN.
Minister reply
Yemen remains a priority area for the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office. The Minister has spoken to Martin Griffiths about further support for his work towards bringing about a sustainable ceasefire, but cannot commit at this stage to Tobias Ellwood's specific points.
Gill Furniss
Lab
Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough
Question
The humanitarian crisis in Yemen is worsening with 80% of the population needing aid. Blockades are restricting access, leading to a significant number of children under five facing acute malnutrition this year alone. Gill Furniss criticises the reduction of support as Yemen battles coronavirus and faces cholera outbreaks, questioning how it aligns with the UK's pledge to build a global Britain.
Minister reply
The Minister acknowledges concerns over humanitarian access routes and is proud of the Government’s efforts in lobbying international partners and providing technical support for aid distribution. He also commits to continue providing financial and technical assistance while working towards ending the conflict.
David Mundell
Con
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
Question
David Mundell emphasises the need for effective aid in Yemen. He asks about recent discussions with international counterparts regarding a panel of experts’ report on Yemen and invites the Minister to meet representatives from humanitarian organisations, local NGOs, and the Yemeni private sector to address serious shortcomings and factual inaccuracies contained within the report.
Minister reply
The Minister acknowledges the importance of addressing allegations made in the panel’s recent report. He agrees with their vision for accountability from the Government of Yemen and its central bank and is willing to facilitate a meeting involving knowledgeable individuals.
Zarah Sultana
Lab
Coventry South
Question
Despite declaring that improving the situation for Yemenis was a priority, Zarah Sultana criticises the Government’s 50% cut in aid and questions how this aligns with their commitment. She also points out the £6.7 billion-worth of arms sales to Saudi Arabia since the start of the war, calling on the Minister to take necessary actions for peace by ending these arms sales.
Minister reply
The Minister responds that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is defending itself against Houthi aggression and highlights the robustness of the UK's arms export regime. He reiterates that encouraging all parties involved in Yemen, including regional partners, to bring an end to the conflict is the best approach.
Shadow Comment
Andrew Mitchell
Shadow Comment
The shadow, Andrew Mitchell, criticised the decision to cut aid by over 50%, terming it 'unconscionable' during a global pandemic. He pointed out that despite previous assurances of Yemen's status as a UK priority and the promise to maintain the 0.7% official development assistance commitment, the current cuts are detrimental to millions of Yemeni children and represent strategic failure with deadly consequences.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.