← Back to House of Commons Debates
Christmas Adjournment
20 December 2022
Lead MP
Bob Blackman
Debate Type
General Debate
Tags
UkraineEconomyTaxationTransportBrexitBusiness & Trade
Other Contributors: 46
At a Glance
Bob Blackman raised concerns about christmas adjournment in the House of Commons. Other MPs contributed to the debate.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
The Conservative party has taken control of Harrow Council and implemented policies such as free parking tickets, enforcement of fly-tipping measures, reduced height limits for developments, a customer experience action plan, and financial reforms. The Labour Mayor's decision to introduce an ultra low emission zone in London is opposed due to its impact on drivers and public transport reliability. There are concerns about family members stuck in Afghanistan under the Taliban, security risks from Russian spies posing as Ukrainian refugees, and the situation in Iran regarding protests and human rights violations. Additionally, there are issues related to interfaith relations, homelessness prevention, smoking reduction goals, international trade deals with India, and political stability in Israel.
Bob Blackman
Con
Harrow East
The Conservative party has taken control of Harrow Council. It implemented policies such as providing free parking tickets to revitalise high streets, addressing illegal fly-tipping and houses in multiple occupation, enforcing stricter development regulations, and improving customer interaction with the council. The previous Labour administration left a financial deficit of £15 million and used up all reserves, which the new administration is now correcting with a 10-point plan to control expenditure. Concerns over the London Mayor's decision to introduce an ultra low emission zone are raised due to its potential impact on drivers and public transport reliability in Harrow.
Roger Gale
Con
Herne Bay and Sandwich
The debate was opened with reminders about the need for all Members to remain for winding-up speeches, and a suggestion that Back-Bench speeches should be limited to around seven minutes to accommodate everyone.
Lilian Greenwood
Lab
Nottingham South
Greenwood criticised the Government's inaction on poverty, low wages, homelessness, debt, and desperation. She cited examples such as pensioners struggling with high energy bills and children going to bed hungry due to lack of food. She also highlighted NHS staff facing financial difficulties and leaving their jobs, leading to additional costs for the service. Greenwood further pointed out that firefighters in Nottinghamshire are underfunded and understaffed, resulting in slower response times and potential cuts to fire appliances. She emphasised the need for increased funding for local councils and development projects like Broadmarsh redevelopment to stimulate economic growth.
Fiona Bruce
Con
Congleton
Raised points on education funding for Eaton Bank Academy and refurbishment of Sandbach School; asked the Secretary of State to address concerns about town councils' management; supported extension of bovine TB culling policy in Cheshire; welcomed new homes ombudsman service but requested further support for homeowners; expressed satisfaction with action taken by Cheshire East Council regarding sports pitches in Alsager; called on Ministers to ensure compliance of train operators with franchise agreements and improve Avanti West Coast services; proposed review of small business rate relief threshold post-business rates revaluation; condemned sentencing of Baha’i leaders in Iran and highlighted the humanitarian plight faced by Armenians due to a blockade.
Chris Bryant
Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Describes the current state of affairs as broken and bust, citing numerous examples such as delays in passport issuance, GP appointments, ambulance responses, train cancellations, and medicine shortages. He highlights that public sector workers face real-term cuts over 12 years leading to anger and worry among them. Additionally, he raises concerns about local authority budget gaps affecting swimming pools, leisure centres, and schools.
Bob Stewart
Ind
Marks the 40th anniversary of the Ballykelly bomb incident on 6 December 1982, where 17 young people were killed including soldiers and civilians. Pays tribute to those who have organised commemorations over the years and reads out the names of the deceased as a mark of respect.
Kim Leadbeater
Lab
Spen Valley
Kim Leadbeater reflects on her role in parliamentary committees such as the Online Safety Bill Committee, where she worked to secure Zach's Law. She also discusses community issues like healthcare access and levelling-up initiatives for Batley town centre. She criticises the lack of progress in these areas due to government delays and internal issues.
Mark Francois
Con
Rayleigh and Wickford
Mr Francois highlighted issues such as the closure of King Edmund School due to asbestos discovery during demolition work. He emphasised the delays in clearance and safety concerns for pupils and parents. Additionally, he mentioned persistent lift problems at King George’s Court leading to a hazardous situation where an elderly resident had to be manhandled down stairs due to the out-of-service lift. Francois also discussed the threat of an ancient oak tree being demolished by Bloor Homes and called for the Competition and Markets Authority to investigate the house building industry's overconcentration, citing his experience with Bloor Homes as evidence of the need for such action. Finally, he addressed severe pressures on ambulance crews at Southend Hospital due to delays in patient discharge.
Jeremy Corbyn
Ind
Islington North
Corbyn emphasised the dire situation faced by nurses, postal workers, rail workers, and teachers. He criticised inadequate pay rises, increased workloads, and poor working conditions, urging the Government to meet with unions to address these issues. He also pointed out that workers are resorting to food banks due to low wages.
Navendu Mishra
Lab
Stockport
Mishra visited local Royal Mail workers and observed an agenda to reduce their jobs to zero-hours, gig economy positions. He criticised the failure of senior management at Royal Mail to reach an agreement with CWU.
Martin Vickers
Con
Brigg and Immingham
He criticised the right hon. Member for Islington North, Jeremy Corbyn, for aligning with striking workers causing public inconvenience. He highlighted the poor train service provided by TransPennine Express to his constituents since November last year due to driver training issues. Vickers urged the Leader of the House to reconsider withdrawing TransPennine's franchise and called for reinstating a direct rail link from Cleethorpes to King’s Cross, which was withdrawn in 1992. He also emphasised the importance of granting freeports designation to Humber ports as part of levelling up initiatives.
Navendu Mishra
Lab
Stockport
Intervened to raise concerns about TransPennine Express and Avanti West Coast being owned by FirstGroup, which he believes is mismanaging both franchises. He supported Vickers' call for TransPennine Express's franchise to be stripped but also called for FirstGroup to lose the Avanti West Coast franchise.
Rachel Hopkins
Lab
Luton South and South Bedfordshire
Expressed gratitude towards her family and friends for their support. Highlighted the importance of breast cancer screenings and thanked NHS workers, particularly nurses, who are overworked due to understaffing and burnout but remain professional and compassionate despite this Government's refusal to negotiate a fair deal with nursing unions. She acknowledged the increased burden on voluntary, community, and charitable organisations in providing essential services as a result of years of cuts by this Conservative government.
Luke Evans
Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
The speech highlighted the rapid advancement in artificial intelligence, emphasising its impact on various sectors including economy, health care, and education. The hon. Gentleman also raised concerns about the ethical implications of AI, such as autonomy, liability, fairness, safety, morality, and ownership of creativity. He proposed the need for a dedicated regulator to oversee AI development alongside existing initiatives like the National AI Strategy.
Asked if the speech was written by artificial intelligence or himself.
Navendu Mishra
Lab
Stockport
Critiqued the debt collection practices of local authorities, highlighting a constituent's struggle with council tax arrears and the aggressive tactics employed by debt collectors. Cited statistics showing that over 3.5 million people were behind on their council tax due to the pandemic, adding an average £310 in bailiff fees for those struggling. Emphasised the need for alternative collection methods that do not add further stress for vulnerable individuals and called for a proper policy from the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities. Noted a 32.5% reduction in settlement funding for Stockport Council since 2015-16 due to austerity measures. Highlighted issues with social housing provision, including over 7,000 households on the waiting list in Stockport, and called for adequate funding for building new social housing. Criticised Avanti West Coast's performance and advocated for public ownership of rail services. Showcased support for postal workers' dispute resolution and thanked David Kennedy from CWU branch secretary for his assistance. Congratulated Kate Green on her appointment as Deputy Mayor of Greater Manchester and called for a trade deal that benefits the North West beyond just economic gains, including cultural and educational links. Mentioned the need for direct flights between Manchester Airport and key Indian cities to facilitate easier trade and cultural exchanges.
Peter Gibson
Con
Darlington
Mr Gibson discussed the significant financial support and investments his constituency of Darlington has received, highlighting £620 million in total. He mentioned specific projects like the £23.3 million from the towns fund for improving historical yards and roads, and the permanent location of the Darlington economic campus with over 80% of new jobs going to local people. Additionally, he spoke about the progress on T-levels, the £139 million investment in Bank Top station, the rail heritage quarter project, and railway bridge improvements. He also addressed road projects such as the northern link road inclusion in road investment strategy 3. Furthermore, Mr Gibson emphasised his work strengthening communities through local initiatives like building playgrounds for schools, supporting hospice care, and engaging with various community activities.
Kevin Brennan
Lab
Cardiff West
Kevin Brennan congratulated Dr Evans for introducing the topic of artificial intelligence in the creative industries, particularly focusing on its impact on the music industry. He highlighted both positive and negative aspects: AI could help artists create new compositions more efficiently but also has the potential to replace human musicians and composers or generate counterfeit music. He used an example where a speech was generated by AI, demonstrating how real this technology is. Brennan expressed concern over current lack of regulations in the UK and EU regarding AI use in creative industries and advocated for defending copyright institutions to ensure rights holders receive remuneration for their works.
Richard Graham
Con
Gloucester
Expressed gratitude towards healthcare workers in Gloucestershire and highlighted the importance of creative solutions to address hospital backlogs. Mentioned the need for a balance between supporting healthcare professionals and addressing resource constraints, and emphasised the work done by various organisations abroad such as diplomatic services, trade officers, and the British Council. Praises the efforts made towards international trade relations with Asia, including the trans-Pacific partnership and free trade agreement talks. Acknowledges the significant human rights progress in China regarding its zero-COVID policy reversal while cautioning against counterproductive measures targeting China's domestic issues. Emphasised local success stories like the conversion of a department store into a university campus and the improvement of infrastructure, highlighting the importance of levelling-up initiatives for regional development.
Munira Wilson
Lib Dem
Twickenham
The hon. Member for Twickenham highlighted the challenges facing primary care and ambulance services in Greater London and the south-east, which have been underinvested due to population growth. She mentioned specific cases of individuals struggling to access NHS dentists and called on Ministers to visit areas like Wokingham and Hampton Hill to see these issues firsthand. Wilson also discussed the strain on GPs and A&E departments, citing a case in Winchester where an elderly woman waited seven hours for an ambulance and another six hours at the hospital. She raised concerns about upcoming strikes by NHS workers over pay and conditions and their impact on services. Additionally, she addressed the disruption caused by South Western Railway service cancellations during Christmas, affecting constituents' ability to travel for work or medical appointments.
The hon. Member Nigel Evans called upon speakers to adhere to a time limit of six minutes each to ensure fair participation in the debate before wind-ups take place.
Jo Gideon
Lab
Stoke-on-Trent Central
Called for greater awareness among parents, grandparents, retailers, and manufacturers regarding products containing button batteries. Advocated for specific safety standards such as child-resistant battery compartments, clear warnings at point of sale, and secure packaging to prevent loose batteries.
Gerald Jones
Lab
Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare
He highlighted the case of Pearl Melody Black, whose death due to an unengaged handbrake was not prosecutable under current laws as it occurred on private land. He advocated for legislative changes to prevent similar future incidents and discussed Cuthbert Taylor’s story, a boxer who faced racial discrimination in boxing rules. Jones also addressed the ongoing strikes by workers across various sectors and called for a Labour government that prioritises workers' rights.
Greg Smith
Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
He raised several issues affecting his constituents, including off-grid properties and the need for financial support, GP access in Long Crendon where a new healthcare centre is expected but not yet delivered, banking closures leaving only one high street bank across his constituency, HS2 and East West Rail infrastructure projects causing problems such as road damage and business closures without adequate compensation, and opposition to building a mega-prison near existing construction sites.
Janet Daby
Lab
Lewisham East
She highlighted the Government's failures affecting children’s safety, air quality, community food banks, universal credit issues, school funding for free meals amid rising prices, and visa processing delays impacting refugees and asylum seekers. She emphasised that prevention is better than cure in addressing child health through adequate nutrition and called on the government to show greater compassion towards Afghan refugees.
Don Valley
Nicholas Fletcher highlighted the challenges faced by Doncaster in losing its international airport and called for a public inquiry. He also expressed hope for an end to the war in Ukraine, lower inflation, no more strikes, and a change in political discourse to one of respect.
Matt Rodda
Lab
Reading Central
Matt Rodda raised concerns about Reading jail’s future and proposed turning it into an arts hub. He also mentioned the need for further Government action on legal but harmful content in the Online Safety Bill, reform of business rates policy to support small businesses, and renewed focus on Gurkha pensions.
Andy Carter
Lab
Warrington South
Carter detailed the progress in Warrington South, including new healthcare investments, school improvements, public transport advancements, and ongoing issues such as leasehold mis-selling by David Wilson Homes.
Wera Hobhouse
Lib Dem
Bath
Hobhouse paid tribute to local organisations in Bath while highlighting the health service crisis, including dental shortages, GP recruitment issues, and emergency care pressures. She also raised concerns about energy bill support for residential boaters.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
Discussed the NHS staffing crisis, mentioning that nurses are striking for better pay and working conditions. Highlighted issues such as poor retention rates due to low wages, high vacancy numbers in the NHS, and the financial burden on trusts from agency staff costs. Emphasised the need for urgent negotiations between the government and unions to address these challenges.
Anna Firth
Con
Southend West
Praised Southend's innovative businesses, mentioned the opening of the City Wheel at Adventure Island. Highlighted impressive T-level programmes and apprenticeships in education. Discussed community policing initiatives to tackle knife crime with electronic knife poles. Emphasised the NHS's innovation despite capital funding delays, thanking staff for their dedication. Called on Labour-led council to support Southend becoming a city of culture in 2029. Celebrated local music projects like 'Music is Magic' by The Music Man Project.
Nigel Evans
Con
Ribble Valley
Paid tribute to David Amess for his service, expressing gratitude on behalf of all Members.
Richard Foord
Lib Dem
Honiton and Sidmouth
Reflected on historical events in Honiton, including the Bindon landslip. Discussed the landslide victory in Tiverton by Liberal Democrats at a by-election. Called for swift rebuilding of Tiverton High School and investment in water infrastructure to address recent issues with burst mains and lack of running water in some communities. Highlighted Network Rail's plans for Cullompton railway station reopening. Mentioned Seaton Polar Express tram ride. Urged the Government to deliver on promises regarding schools, water regulation, railways, and bus services. Proposed turning off festive lights as a symbol of support for Ukraine.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Shannon discussed the importance of Christmas from a religious perspective, stressing the hope found in Christ's message. He mentioned various Bible passages and Queen Elizabeth II’s words about Jesus as an inspiration. He expressed thanks to staff members, colleagues, and his constituents for their support.
John Hayes
Con
South Holland and The Deepings
Hayes intervened to express appreciation for Shannon's affirmation of faith, encouraging reflection on the Judeo-Christian foundations that underpin society and civilization.
Mordaunt thanked Shannon for addressing the feelings of loss and separation from family during Christmas. She acknowledged the challenges many face at this time and expressed gratitude for his speech.
Chris Stephens
SNP
Glasgow South West
Responded to the debate, acknowledging its wide-ranging nature and praising contributions from other MPs. He highlighted the cost of living crisis and criticised restrictive trade union laws that make it difficult for workers to take industrial action. Mentioned ongoing civil service strikes and food inflation at 16%. Discussed local initiatives to help people step up from food banks through affordable projects, like community larders and supermarkets. Criticised the increase in sanctions by the Department for Work and Pensions, noting £36 million recouped in August alone. Raised concerns about delays and lack of correspondence on constituent cases with the Home Office.
Jessica Morden
Lab
Newport East
Wished all those who work with her in the House a merry and restful Christmas. Highlighted the chaos surrounding the Government's performance, mentioning multiple ministerial changes and policy failures. Criticised the impact of the mini-Budget on pensioners and the lack of contrition from those responsible for economic failure. Emphasised the need for overdue Bills and White Papers to be addressed. Acknowledged contributions from other MPs regarding broken Britain under this Government, rail services criticism, debt collection practices, AI discussions, safety campaigns, and international concerns such as Ukraine and Nagorno-Karabakh.
Responded briefly with 'Ac i chi' (And to you).
Penny Mordaunt
Con
Portsmouth North
She thanked all hon. Members who spoke, highlighted various contributions including AI usage in speeches, cultural projects like the Music Man project, and trade relations with India. She also addressed topics such as energy efficiency funds for schools, rail services, and healthcare innovations.
Evans
Lab
Bosworth
He spoke about AI and its implications, suggesting that it could be used to improve parliamentary processes and speed up decision-making in line with business and scientific advancements.
Kevin Brennan
Lab
Cardiff West
His speech focused on AI's impact on the music industry and other consumer issues. He acknowledged the importance of voluntary organisations but also criticised certain aspects of government policies such as council tax increases.
Bob Stewart
Con
Beckenham
He spoke movingly about the Ballykelly bombing, remembering those who were killed and emphasising that we will never forget. He highlighted the significance of commemoration in recognising past sacrifices.
Kim Leadbeater
Lab
Batley and Spen
She discussed the Online Safety Bill and its progress since January. She acknowledged it as an important step forward but also called for meetings with organisations such as Solving Kids' Cancer to address further concerns.
Matt Rodda
Lib Dem
Reading East
He addressed issues like the Online Safety Bill and home insulation schemes, emphasising the importance of social and voluntary organisations during challenging times. He also raised questions about energy companies.
Nigel Evans
Con
Ribble Valley
Welcomed Christmas wishes and thanked staff for their hard work. Mentioned the importance of supporting all parliamentary workers from cleaners to security services. Quoted 'It's a Wonderful Life' as an inspiration.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.