The Minister responded to Richard Foord's concerns, outlining the history of NHS reforms in Devon that led to the current situation at Seaton Hospital. She explained that NHS Property Services operates on a cost recovery basis and that any reduction in charges would result in a loss to the health budget unless offset by actual cost reductions. The Minister noted that while local community groups have expressed interest in using some of the empty ward space, the high rental charge is an insurmountable barrier. She emphasised that decisions about the use of NHS property should be taken at a local level and assured that efforts are being made to resolve the situation.