← Back to House of Commons Debates
Israel and Palestine
08 January 2024
Lead MP
Andrew Mitchell
Debate Type
Ministerial Statement
Tags
DefenceTaxationForeign AffairsStandards & Ethics
Other Contributors: 59
At a Glance
Andrew Mitchell raised concerns about israel and palestine in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Government Statement
Andrew Mitchell, reiterating the UK's support for Israel’s right to defend itself against Hamas while emphasising the need for humanitarian aid and a ceasefire, stated that the United Kingdom played a leading role in securing UN Security Council resolution 2720. The resolution demanded expanded humanitarian access and steps toward a sustainable ceasefire. Britain has pushed innovative approaches like maritime delivery to support Gaza, with 87 tonnes of aid delivered by a Royal Navy vessel into Egypt last week. Additionally, 1,065 tonnes of food aid arrived through new humanitarian land corridors from Jordan, partly funded by the UK. The Foreign Secretary and other Ministers are lobbying Israel hard for more aid access and pushing to prevent famine in Gaza. Mitchell warned against further escalation in violence, especially on Lebanon’s southern border with Israel and in the Red Sea where Houthi attacks threaten commercial shipping. He concluded that Gaza should be under Palestinian control as part of a two-state solution.
David Lammy
Lab
Tottenham
Question
Mr Speaker, the Christmas period has not brought peace to the middle east. There has been no let-up to the intolerable suffering in Gaza and no end to the cruelty for hostages. Millions are displaced, desperate and hungry. Israel continues to use devastating tactics that have seen far too many innocent civilians killed, with unacceptable blocks on essential aid, nowhere safe for civilians, a growing humanitarian catastrophe, and now warnings of a deadly famine. Meanwhile, Hamas terrorists continue to hold hostages, hide among civilians and fire rockets into Israel.
This dire situation must not continue. The need for a sustained ceasefire is clear. The fighting must stop urgently. We need a humanitarian truce now—not as a short pause but as the first step towards what will stop the killing of innocents, provide urgent humanitarian relief, ward off famine, free hostages and provide the space for a sustainable ceasefire so that fighting does not restart. I urge the Government to do everything they can to work for a sustained ceasefire, which will also ease the growing regional tensions across the divides and avoid the catastrophe of a wider war. Those risks are rising.
Will the Minister tell the House what steps the Government are taking to urge restraint in Lebanon and to see the full implementation of UN Security Council resolution 1701, which would allow civilians on both sides of the border to return home? In the Red sea, all the targeting of commercial ships and international trade routes that puts civilians and military personnel in danger must stop, so I welcome the approach of the US, the UK, Germany and others to send clear warnings to those responsible. Will the Government ensure that this House has the time and space to scrutinise decisions of any significance that may be required?
Minister reply
I thank the shadow Foreign Secretary for his comments and urge for a sustained ceasefire as the British Government believe is the right approach, securing UN resolution 2720. The Government are moving military assets to ensure conflict containment. Operation Prosperity Guardian is in full swing with HMS Diamond soon joining HMS Lancaster.
Alicia Kearns
Con
Rutland and Stamford
Question
Thank you Mr Speaker.
I welcome the £2 million for additional food and the special envoy that so many of us have been calling for. First, now that Israel says it has dismantled Hamas in the north of Gaza, what are the plans to surge aid into the area, and what are Israel’s plans to rebuild the territory? Secondly, will my right hon. Friend give consideration to my proposal for an Israel-Palestine contact group that can start the hard work of a long-term peace process by kicking off track 2 negotiations?
Minister reply
The Government look at the Chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee’s comments on a contact group extremely carefully, and welcome her support for humanitarian aid co-ordinator efforts. The current problem is not funding but getting food and necessary requirements into Gaza.
Brendan O'Hara
SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Question
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and may I wish you and your staff a very happy new year?
Of course, it has not been a happy new year for the 2 million desperate and terrified people trapped inside Gaza, for whom 2024 brought further constant bombardment as well as the threat of famine and disease, with 50,000 people injured and almost 25,000 confirmed killed. That proves that repeated pleas from this Government and others for Israel to abide by international humanitarian law have been routinely ignored.
Scotland’s First Minister recently described what is happening in Gaza as “tantamount to ethnic cleansing”, and South Africa has asked the International Court of Justice to urgently declare Israel in breach of the 1948 genocide convention for its continued killing of Palestinians, the destruction of homes, the expulsion of people and the blockade of food, water and medical assistance. Do the UK Government think that Scotland’s First Minister and the Government of South Africa are wrong in their assessment of the current situation? If they are wrong, how are they wrong specifically?
Minister reply
The Government respect the ICJ and will follow its matters carefully. It is up to courts to determine these issues; all parties must ensure actions are proportionate and minimise harm to civilians.
Question
What have we learned since we last met? We have learned that Hamas are using North Korean weapons. We have heard of further examples of gender-based violence, we have heard examples of hostages being kept in cages, and we have heard the testimony of a released 17-year-old hostage, Agam Goldstein Almog, who spoke of sexual violence and torture perpetrated against hostages who are still being held. To top it all, in the last few days Jibril Rajoub, a Palestinian Authority representative and the secretary of Fatah’s central committee, has said:
“We view political Islam, and foremost among it the Hamas Movement, as part of the fabric of our struggle and our political and social fabric.”
Given what the Minister has said about the need for a two-state solution and the role of Fatah and the PA in that, what representations is he making to the PA about the radicalised language that they are using?
Minister reply
The Government urge everyone to exercise restraint in their language. The extensive reporting on 7 October must be read by all Members. Britain and our allies are doing a great deal of work to secure a better arrangement for the Palestinian Authority when fighting stops.
Hayes and Harlington
Question
As the Minister will know, a large number of children are being killed or injured as a result of the conflict. Hospital facilities in Gaza have collapsed. Will the Minister convene a meeting with NGOs to establish what further assistance our country could give?
Minister reply
The right hon. Gentleman is correct about the plight of children and we are working closely with NGOs, considering a UK medical team's contribution, especially field hospitals.
Tobias Ellwood
Con
Not specified
Question
What will happen if shipping is further targeted in international waters? Will the Government attack silos from which missiles are launched?
Minister reply
HMS Diamond has shot down an attack drone, and the Government have made it clear that they will not accept the fettering of navigation rights.
Apsana Begum
Lab
Poplar and Limehouse
Question
Medical Aid For Palestinians reports that Al-Aqsa hospital has been forced to close due to increasing Israeli military activity. Will the Government's support for bombing apply in every conflict, or only in Gaza?
Minister reply
All parties must ensure their actions are proportionate and necessary to minimise harm to civilians.
Alec Shelbrooke
Con
Wetherby and Easingwold
Question
Are the Government discussing in the Arab region to get Hamas to move away from its stated aims of destroying Israel?
Minister reply
The British Government are doing everything possible through various means to prosecute that case.
Paul Blomfield
Lab
Not specified
Question
Said Zaaneen, a PhD student at the University of Sheffield, is trapped in Gaza. Can the Minister extend eligibility for Foreign Office lists to those Palestinian nationals who are middle of courses at UK universities?
Minister reply
The hon Gentleman and I will have a chat immediately after this urgent question.
Nicola Richards
Lab
Not specified
Question
Women and girls reported to have been raped or mutilated by Hamas in Israel. What assessment has my right hon Friend's Department made of the emerging evidence? Has he had conversations with the Red Cross?
Minister reply
Our contact and heavy involvement with the Red Cross is happening daily, and we will do everything possible to ensure there will not be impunity for those who commit these horrendous crimes.
Steve McCabe
Lab
Not specified
Question
The Israeli Defence Minister has set out proposals for post-war governance involving a multinational taskforce. What is the British Government’s assessment of those proposals?
Minister reply
We greatly welcome all constructive proposals, and we agree that when this dreadful conflict is over, Gaza must be run by Palestinians.
Will Quince
Con
Not specified
Question
The World Health Organisation has warned about overcrowding and inadequate food, water, shelter and sanitation. What steps are being taken to support partners on the ground in Gaza?
Minister reply
We are intent on trying to get the number of trucks that get into Gaza up to 500 a day and have deployed this medical team.
Richard Foord
Lib Dem
Honiton and Sidmouth
Question
What confidence does the Minister have that Israel will conduct its counter-insurgency operations in such a way as to abide by international humanitarian law?
Minister reply
All parties must ensure their actions are proportionate, necessary and minimise harm to civilians.
Kit Malthouse
Con
North West Hampshire
Question
Does the Minister agree that something more draconian may be needed to deter worsening activity by violent settlers? Would he look at instituting immediate bans on trade with settlements?
Minister reply
We are opposed to boycotts, divestments and sanctions.
Afzal Khan
Lab
Manchester Rusholme
Question
Senior representatives of Israel continue to use language endorsing genocide against Palestinians. Will the Minister now condemn her genocidal words and commit to taking the strongest possible action?
Minister reply
In respect of humanitarian difficulties, we are doing everything we can to try to secure unhindered humanitarian access.
Julian Lewis
Con
New Forest East
Question
Given that Hamas will never accept a two-state solution, does the Minister agree that any two-state solution must exclude Hamas—or any renamed successor—from any role in the government of Gaza?
Minister reply
There is clearly no place in any future settlement for Hamas and their vile ideology and terrorist actions.
Stella Creasy
Lab Co-op
Walthamstow
Question
Asked the Minister about the UK's position on the International Court of Justice case brought by South Africa regarding Israel and Gaza, seeking clarity on whether all parties should abide by any outcomes from it.
Minister reply
The Government support accountability mechanisms for alleged war crimes but do not want a culture of impunity. They respect the role of the international court and are following its proceedings closely.
Question
Inquired about the welfare of hostages in Gaza, including children among them, asking whether there is a strategy to ensure their wellbeing.
Minister reply
The Government are working closely with other countries to secure the release of hostages and have deployed a medical team to help address humanitarian issues.
Question
Inquired about the South African application to the International Court of Justice and whether it seems prima facie that Israel has committed serious breaches of international law.
Minister reply
The court must determine such matters, not politicians. The Minister has been briefed on the 84-page submission but has not read all pages.
Question
Asked about the adequacy of the Economic Activity of Public Bodies (Overseas Matters) Bill in reflecting concerns over illegal and violent Israeli activities in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Minister reply
The Government believe public bodies should not waste public money on foreign policy, but these points will be discussed properly when the bill is debated on Wednesday.
Richard Burgon
Lab
Leeds East
Question
Pressed for a commitment to call for an immediate ceasefire if the International Court of Justice orders Israel to suspend military operations.
Minister reply
The Government do not support an immediate ceasefire, and they believe it is important to wait and see what the court decides.
Bob Blackman
Con
Harrow East
Question
Asked about efforts to ensure the Red Cross can access hostages in Gaza, including their health needs.
Minister reply
The Government are continuously working with the Red Cross and allies to secure the release of hostages.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Question
Inquired about potential progress towards a ceasefire, hostage release, and peace negotiations involving UK mediation.
Minister reply
The Government support efforts for peace but focus on securing the release of hostages and addressing humanitarian issues.
Question
Asked about preparations to send volunteer medical practitioners to Gaza post-ceasefire, referencing local community engagement in his constituency.
Minister reply
The Minister acknowledged the work being done by communities engaged with Gaza and noted the point made.
Debbie Abrahams
Lab
Oldham East and Saddleworth
Question
Pressed for support of ICC investigations into potential war crimes in Gaza, emphasising proportionality and necessity.
Minister reply
The Government emphasise the importance of ensuring all actions are proportionate and necessary to prevent civilian harm.
Question
Asked for clarification on conditions necessary for a sustainable ceasefire, referencing Security Council resolution 2720.
Minister reply
A sustainable ceasefire should enable relief efforts in Gaza and the Government are working towards this goal.
Rushanara Ali
Lab
Bethnal Green and Stepney
Question
Suggested using lessons from The Gambia's ICJ case to apply pressure on both Israeli and Hamas for a ceasefire.
Minister reply
The Government are exerting pressure with American allies but cautions against seeing direct analogies between the Gambian and South African cases.
Flick Drummond
Lab
Dartford
Question
In light of recent comments by Israeli Ministers and the Israeli ambassador to the UK, what steps have the UK Government taken to ensure that Palestinians can return to their homes in Gaza as soon as conditions allow?
Minister reply
The Government have made it absolutely clear that there can be no resettlement of Palestinians outside of Gaza: those who lived in Gaza before must have the right of return and the British Government have been unequivocal on that point.
Beth Winter
Lab
Halifax
Question
Will the Minister condemn his Israeli counterpart for seeking to permanently displace Palestinians from their homes, confirm that Members of the Israeli Government are advocating for breaches of international law and agree that the actions of the Israeli state contravene the genocide convention? As a first step, will he call for an immediate ceasefire?
Minister reply
The hon. Lady will be aware of the arguments for a sustainable ceasefire that are propagated by the Government and supported by the Opposition Front Bench. She is entirely right about the suffering and in respect of her first point, she will have heard what I said to two of her hon. Friends.
Rob Butler
Con
Aylesbury
Question
Will he reassure me and my constituents that his Department will continue to keep food aid and medical aid to Gaza under review, and redouble its efforts to work with neighbouring countries to ensure that aid gets where it is needed most?
Minister reply
Yes, Mr Speaker, I can give my hon. Friend that assurance. He refers to the £2 million that was specifically allocated to the convoy from Jordan but he should be aware that the contribution Britain is making is far more extensive and includes four air flights into el-Arish and the naval operation I described.
Gavin Newlands
SNP
Paisley and Renfrewshire North
Question
Why are this Government so quick—and rightly—to condemn Russia’s war crimes, but not Israel’s war crimes?
Minister reply
The British Government and indeed the Opposition stand up for international humanitarian law and condemn breaches of it whenever they take place. That is why from this Dispatch Box, throughout these terrible days since 7 October, we have consistently appealed to everyone to stand by international humanitarian law.
Michael Ellis
Con
Canterbury
Question
Does my right hon. Friend agree that His Majesty’s Government should do the same and criticise South Africa’s action?
Minister reply
The South Africans are entitled under the rules to refer the matter to the International Court of Justice in the way that they have and, as I have repeatedly said, there will be different views across the House on whether it is helpful to do so at this stage.
Andrew Slaughter
Lab
Hammersmith and Chiswick
Question
What steps are the Government taking to restrain Israel from breaking international law?
Minister reply
In respect of the discussions to which the hon. Gentleman refers, I can assure him that the British Government hold those discussions all the time.
Colum Eastwood
SDLP
Foyle
Question
Has the Foreign Secretary hauled her in to explain that this Government oppose that policy?
Minister reply
The British Government make their views very clear at all times; I have just given the hon. Gentleman a list of all the different people the Prime Minister has been engaged with since this awful conflict started.
Alison McGovern
Lab
Birkenhead
Question
How is his humanitarian strategy responding to the desperate needs of children affected by the conflict?
Minister reply
We are trying to ensure that 500 trucks a day get in to provide the humanitarian aid the hon. Lady is talking about.
Andrew Bridgen
Con
Warwick and Leamington
Question
Does the Minister still believe that the Israel Defence Forces response remains proportionate?
Minister reply
I really do not think that the equation that the hon. Gentleman makes between barbaric death in that way is one that stands very close scrutiny.
Rupa Huq
Lab
Ealing Central and Acton
Question
Are we not just greenlighting a leader who was already unpopular before all this and who cares less about pinpoint accuracy and international law?
Minister reply
The longevity or otherwise of the Prime Minister of Israel is a matter for the Israeli people.
Stephen Farry
Alliance
East Antrim
Question
Why the double standards? Is it credible to continue with them?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman draws attention to the point that I have been making—that we are always standing up for international humanitarian law; it does not matter where there are breaches.
Stephen Timms
Lab
East Ham
Question
The Minister has supported a two-state solution, with Gaza under Palestinian control, but the proposals tabled last week by the Israeli Defence Minister are very different, envisaging a subsidiary status of some kind for Palestine. How in practice does the Minister envisage the two-state model being taken forward once the conflict ends?
Minister reply
The right hon. Gentleman is entirely correct to say that a number of proposals are being generated, some of which are being given voice at this moment. But the critical thing is that, when this dreadful conflict ceases, there will be a moment for the political track to assert itself.
Question
The Minister himself acknowledged that the spectre of famine is stalking Gaza. I applaud his aim to restore the pre-war level of 500 or so trucks going into Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid, but will he tell us how many trucks actually went through in the last 24 hours? Is it true that in some cases trucks are waiting up to 15 days for clearance and that trucks are taken out of the convoy of aid because one item has failed security checks?
Minister reply
I thank the hon. Lady for her comments. Currently, around 150 trucks a day are getting in—[Interruption.] That is, as she is indicating from a sedentary position, entirely inadequate, but we are trying to make sure that the number rises to 500.
Question
The Minister has referred multiple times to the application of international law. What definition of proportionate, targeted and minimising are the Government applying if they consider the actions of Israel to be in compliance with all of those? How many children have to be killed before the Government stop the linguistic gymnastics and call for an immediate ceasefire?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman will have heard what I said about the importance of a sustainable ceasefire. He will have heard much the same from the official Opposition.
Question
On 11 December, along with other parliamentarians, I heard the harrowing eyewitness account of Dr Ghassan Abu-Sittah, a British-Palestinian surgeon who had recently returned from Gaza. He spoke of the desperate state of the healthcare provision there, with a lack of essential supplies and no morphine for patients after surgery. Will the Government put pressure on Israel to allow the delivery of those vital supplies?
Minister reply
I have set out the reasons why calling for a permanent ceasefire is not, in our opinion, the right way to proceed. We need to call, as the United Nations resolution does, for a sustainable ceasefire.
Question
We know that women and children make up about 70% of the more than 22,000 people who have been killed in Gaza. That is a horrific number, and should be called such. Does the Minister recognise the particular impact on innocent women and children, and the urgent need, therefore, for a ceasefire to protect them now and in the future?
Minister reply
I recognise entirely what the hon. Lady says about the plight of innocent women and children caught up in these horrendous circumstances.
James Murray
Lab Co-op
Ealing North
Question
The suffering in Gaza over the last three months has been intolerable. I have spoken with many constituents about how unbearable it is to see, day after day, innocent civilians, particularly children, being killed. We urgently need to get to a sustainable ceasefire. What discussions have the UK Government had with international allies about the future of Gaza once the fighting has come to an end?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman correctly sets out the challenge and the requirement for us all.
Clive Betts
Lab
Sheffield South East
Question
Has the Minister made clear to the Israeli Government his criticism of the comments of the Israeli ambassador in which she explicitly rejected a two-state solution, what has the response of the Israeli Prime Minister been?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman will know that there are many different voices coming out of Israel.
Question
The Israeli Government have demanded full control of the Philadelphi corridor, the land border between Gaza and Egypt. As the Minister himself said earlier, it is the main aid corridor for UK and international aid into Gaza. How concerned are the British Government about the Israeli Government’s demands in respect of the Philadelphi corridor?
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman will have seen the progress that has been made on other forms of access.
Tan Dhesi
Lab
Slough
Question
Young women just out of school remain in captivity, facing rape and sexual violence as a weapon of war by Hamas. That is why the likes of me have been calling for, and voting for, an end to the violence. Does the Minister agree that we should call for a humanitarian truce?
Minister reply
I agree with the hon. Gentleman that we are seeking humanitarian pauses.
Toby Perkins
Lab
Chesterfield
Question
Young women just out of school remain in captivity, facing rape and sexual violence as a weapon of war by Hamas. On the other side, senior politicians and the Israeli ambassador now feel the confidence to be able to declare that a two-state solution is off the table, completely ruling out the position that the Minister articulates.
Minister reply
Nothing secret is engaged here.
Emma Hardy
Lab
Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice
Question
It was pleasing to hear the Minister say that Gaza must be run by Palestinians and that there should be no forced resettlement of Palestinians. I am deeply concerned by the comments made by the Israeli ambassador condemning the two-state solution. Further to the response that the Minister gave to my hon. Friends, will he outline whether there is an international coalition for a two-state solution? How powerful is this international coalition? How much influence does it have over Israel, and what is Britain’s role within it?
Minister reply
Throughout all the difficulties, there has been a solid, constant refrain that there has to be a two-state solution, with both Israel and Palestine living in peace behind secure borders. If the hon. Lady reads the speeches made at the United Nations by many of the countries to which she refers, I think she will draw hope from their consistency.
Question
Over Christmas, I heard from a constituent whose sister and her sister’s four children are stuck in Gaza. If there were a ceasefire, it might be easier for them to leave Gaza. If the UK were prepared to offer humanitarian visas to relatives of UK citizens who are in Gaza, it might be easier for them to leave. What is the Minister’s message to my constituent, her sister and her sister’s young children who are trapped in Gaza?
Minister reply
It is difficult for me to comment on a specific case but, if the hon. Gentleman wishes to discuss it with me after this urgent question, I would be happy to see him. He will know that 300 British nationals have been able to leave, thanks not least to the hard work of the brilliant young men and women who are working in the emergency centre at the Foreign Office in London. A small number remain, but we are working literally night and day to make sure we do everything we can to look after our citizens and their relations.
Andrew Gwynne
Ind
Gorton and Denton
Question
The Minister mentioned Oslo in response to my right hon. Friend the Member for East Ham (Sir Stephen Timms). The sad truth is that Prime Minister Netanyahu never really supported Oslo and a two-state solution, and Hamas definitely do not. The two have thrived off each other’s absolutist positions over the past few decades. For those of us who do believe in Oslo, in the peace process and in two states for two peoples, what happens next really matters. The Minister says he wants to secure better arrangements for the Palestinian Authority after the fighting ends. What does he mean by that?
Minister reply
The Foreign Secretary has engaged with both the Palestinian Authority’s Foreign Minister and President Abbas. Britain wants to support the Palestinian Authority in further developing the sinews of statehood that will be required if there is to be a two-state solution, as I hope there will be one day.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
Question
In the light of Tzipi Hotovely’s statement on LBC radio that the destruction of Gaza should continue and be extensive, why have the Government not condemned those words, which drew back on her previous comments about a two-state solution? What is the Minister going to do, because this is inconsistent with everything he is saying at the Dispatch Box?
Minister reply
No one wants to see wanton destruction, which is why I have been very clear about international humanitarian law. I also hope the hon. Lady would assert that, given the horrendous events of 7 October, Israel has a right to self-defence.
Question
I am struggling to understand what the Government’s response is, apart from surprise at the use of extremist language. What chance can there be for the humanitarian truce that is needed now, and for a sustainable ceasefire and a lasting peace, when extremist views are uttered not just by terrorist organisations but by some Ministers and diplomats representing the Israeli Government?
Minister reply
Many wild statements have been made, some with which Members will agree and others with which they will not, but the British Government’s purpose is to achieve a sustainable ceasefire and to meet the immense humanitarian need. It is then to lift people’s eyes, when this terrible conflict is over, to the possibilities of peace that a political track can deliver.
Question
A great many of my constituents write to me on a daily basis demanding that the Government change their position to deliver a ceasefire, but on the point about language, when Israeli Ministers Smotrich and Ben-Gvir said that Gaza should be essentially free of Palestinians, the Government, along with European counterparts, correctly condemned them, but when the ambassador in London called for Gaza to be flattened even more than it already has been, they say nothing. Why?
Minister reply
I have explained the Government policy in some detail both in respect of tackling the humanitarian need that so manifestly exists and in developing the political track when this conflict is over, and I very much hope that the hon. Gentleman and his party will feel able to support that.
Emma Lewell
Lab
South Shields
Question
The UN has described Gaza as a ‘graveyard for children’; it is reported that more than 9,000 have been killed and thousands more severely injured. Those children who have survived face a bleak future, with limited access to aid as bombs continue to rain down on them. Many have lost their parents and their entire families. I heard the Minister’s earlier responses, but can he explain in more detail why the Government support unaccompanied children fleeing Ukraine but cannot set up similar support for children in Gaza?
Minister reply
I do not think that the two situations are analogous, but I do think it is very important that we do everything we can to help the children and the others in Gaza whom the hon. Lady describes, and we will continue to do exactly that.
Cat Smith
Lab
Lancaster and Wyre
Question
Further to that question, we know that children are seven times more likely than adults to be killed by blast injuries and that 1,000 children have lost one or both legs in the last three months in Gaza. The scars that Gazan children are bearing from this war will be long-lasting, so does the Minister agree that to have that two-state solution—that long and lasting peace—we need to step up as part of an international community to defend Gazan children?
Minister reply
The plight of Gazan children will weigh heavily on all decent people on all sides of the argument being expressed in the House this afternoon. The Government will continue to do everything we can, but in terms of the long-term point the hon. Lady made about the two-state solution, all of our diplomatic and political efforts are bent towards trying to secure that.
Matt Western
Lab
Warwick and Leamington
Question
After almost 23,000 civilian deaths, including almost 10,000 children, many observers are describing the atrocity in Gaza as a genocide. I take the Minister at his word on his belief that we need to see a two-state solution. However, last week we heard Bezalel Smotrich, the Finance Minister, describing the need for voluntary emigration from Gaza and Israeli occupation and resettlement of Gaza, and we heard Prime Minister Netanyahu and Ambassador Hotovely describing what they want to see, which is the outright destruction of Hamas and the Palestinian people. I think we need to be honest: when Netanyahu calls for a total victory, he wants to see the annihilation of the Palestinian people, doesn’t he?
Minister reply
I do not think that a close observation of Mr Netanyahu’s remarks would sustain that view. The point the hon. Gentleman is making underlines how important it is for people to be moderate in their language as we seek to move through this dreadful crisis, both in humanitarian terms and ceasefire terms, to the point beyond, when there can be a political track with some hope of success.
Mary Foy
Lab
City of Durham
Question
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. Is the Minister aware that before Christmas a sniper murdered two women—a mother and a daughter—inside the Holy Family parish in Gaza? The Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem stated that the women were shot in cold blood inside the premises of the parish, where there are no belligerents. Pope Francis has condemned the attack, as has the Archbishop of Westminster; will the Government do so?
Minister reply
We are not clear about the full facts of what happened. We have of course heard what the Holy Father has said and what others have said as well, but the fact that any innocent person loses their life in these horrendous circumstances is something which the whole House will deplore.
Shadow Comment
David Lammy
Shadow Comment
David Lammy criticised the ongoing suffering in Gaza, noting millions are displaced and hungry with warnings of famine due to blockades on essential aid. He called for an immediate humanitarian truce leading to a sustainable ceasefire to ease regional tensions and prevent further violence. Lammy questioned steps being taken by the Government regarding restraint in Lebanon, implementation of UN Security Council resolution 1701, and actions against targeting commercial ships in the Red Sea.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.