← Back to House of Commons Debates
United Front Work Department
16 December 2024
Lead MP
Dan Jarvis
Debate Type
Ministerial Statement
Tags
ClimateDemocracy & Elections
Other Contributors: 29
At a Glance
Dan Jarvis raised concerns about united front work department in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Government Statement
The minister emphasised the government's commitment to national security and welcomed the court’s decision upholding the Home Office position on Yang Tengbo, who was excluded due to potential threats. He highlighted the current complex threat environment involving China, Russia, and Iran, noting that the National Security Act 2023 has charged six individuals under it so far. The government plans to roll out the foreign influence registration scheme (FIRS) in summer with regulations laid down in early 2024. The minister stated the UK will cooperate strategically while challenging when necessary on issues like human rights and climate change.
Chingford and Woodford Green
Question
Mr Speaker, I apologise if that was the case. Yang Tengbo—H6—was not a lone wolf but one of some 40,000 United Front Work Department members. The Intelligence and Security Committee report highlighted their penetration of UK sectors such as spying, intellectual property theft, influence, and shaping institutions. Agents are frustrated by insufficient action due to inadequate tools. Will the Government commit to putting China in the enhanced tier of FIRS immediately? Parliamentarians face exposure to the United Front regularly. How will this be remedied today? Former Security Minister Tom Tugendhat stated that naming China in the enhanced tier was ready but has not happened yet. Reports suggest pressure from banks, business community and Government Departments against it. A known security threat was allowed near a royal family member without proper scrutiny.
Minister reply
The FIRS is being prepared for implementation with more people working on its readiness now than ever before. The scheme will go live in the summer after regulations are laid down early next year, providing three months' notice to affected parties. Work continues to identify foreign powers for the enhanced tier based on security and intelligence analysis.
Chris Murray
Lab
Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
Question
Given the complex threat environment from hostile state actors, what plans are there in the King’s Speech for a new Bill on cyber-resilience to protect critical national infrastructure?
Minister reply
The Government is progressing these matters with colleagues across government departments. Critical national infrastructure resilience against threats will be prioritised using all necessary measures.
Chris Philp
Con
Croydon South
Question
Can I start by thanking the Security Minister and the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster for the security briefing they arranged earlier today for the shadow Foreign Secretary and myself? We are grateful for the assistance... The Opposition will fully support the Government in working to secure our nation’s safety, and I will ask the Minister one or two questions in that spirit...
Minister reply
First, we were pleased to offer that briefing because these are important matters that should not divide us. It will always be this Government’s approach that, where we can work co-operatively with all Members of this House on matters relating to national security, we will seek to do so... I hope I have been able to provide some reassurance on the Government’s intention to table the regulations as soon as practically possible in the new year, with a view to having the scheme up and running by the summer...
Neil Coyle
Lab
Bermondsey and Old Southwark
Question
Will the broader China audit include an assessment of the number of Chinese Communist party operatives working in the UK, including through bodies such as the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office? And will the Minister ensure that everyone targeted... has access to tailored security support?
Minister reply
We are working with other Departments to carry out an audit of the UK’s relationship with China. This is being done to improve our ability to understand and respond to both the challenges and the opportunities that China poses... BNO status holders and their families are making significant contributions to our economy and local communities. From the route’s introduction on 31 January 2021 to the end of September 7, more than 215,000 visas were granted.
Christine Jardine
Lib Dem
Edinburgh West
Question
I thank the right hon. Member for Chingford and Woodford Green (Sir Iain Duncan Smith) for securing this urgent question on a crucial issue... We need robust action to clamp down on things like the police stations that we have heard exist in this country. The Government say they are seeking closer relationships with China, so how can the Minister reassure us that they will not weaken their stance or robustness against Chinese influence in this country...
Minister reply
I can assure the hon. Lady that this Government are, and will be, taking the robust action required to combat the nature of the threat... In truth, we have to balance that relationship, but I can give her an assurance that we will take the robust action required, including through the defending democracy taskforce...
Amanda Martin
Lab
Portsmouth North
Question
Members from across the House are right to raise concerns about the security threats and attempts to undermine or infiltrate our institutions that we face from China. On behalf of all Members of the House, will the Minister pass on our thanks...?
Minister reply
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for making that point. By necessity, the work that our intelligence services do is in the shadows... I will ensure that is passed on.
Karen Bradley
Con
Staffordshire Moorlands
Question
May I urge the Minister to introduce the FIRS scheme as soon as possible and commence it at the earliest possible opportunity? What steps has the Home Office taken...?
Minister reply
I am grateful to the Chair of the Home Affairs Committee for her questions; I know the Home Secretary is looking forward to appearing in front of the Committee tomorrow. On the embassy, as the right hon. Lady will know, the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government has called in the application... A final decision will be made in due course.
Paul Waugh
Lab Co-op
Rochdale
Question
The shadow Home Secretary referred to “sycophancy” towards the Chinese, but I think that charge is better directed at Members of his own party... Does the Minister agree that this is not the right approach to the Chinese?
Minister reply
I agree that is not the right approach; the current Government’s approach is the right one. I have laid out the strategic approach we intend to adopt with China...
Suella Braverman
Con
Fareham and Waterlooville
Question
Last year, as Home Secretary, I made the decision to exclude Yang Tengbo from the UK because his presence posed a threat to our national security. That decision was based on the advice of MI5, and I am very pleased that the High Court has upheld that decision. If the Government are really serious about tackling the unprecedented threat posed by China—malicious cyber-attacks, transnational repression, Confucius institutes, Chinese police stations, and human rights abuses against the Uyghur Muslims—when will they list China on the enhanced tier?
Minister reply
The Minister points out that he did not initially intend to address this issue but felt compelled to respond due to the Home Secretary's questioning. The Minister asserts that the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme was not ready when his government took office, and they are now working closely with colleagues across Government to implement it by summer. However, the Minister declines to commit on whether China will be listed in the enhanced tier.
Dan Aldridge
Lab
Weston-super-Mare
Question
It is disappointing that some Opposition Members are trying to turn what should be a moment of collective unity in the face of a shared security threat into a political row. Does the Security Minister agree that it is pretty incredible for the party whose Defence Secretary was sacked for leaking vital intelligence about the Huawei 5G contract now to pose as the protector of our national security?
Minister reply
The Minister agrees with his hon. Friend's sentiment, noting that the Government will work constructively across the House on matters relating to national security but suggests that Opposition Members should exercise humility given their past actions.
Thomas Tugendhat
Con
Tonbridge
Question
The Minister is assured by officials who sit in the Box advising him that the scheme would be ready to go by the end of the year. Clearly, something has changed with the new government leading it. The real question is whether it will be worth having if China is not in the enhanced tier.
Minister reply
The Minister confirms that the scheme was not ready when his government took office and assures the House that they are working at pace to implement it by summer, without committing on whether China will be listed in the enhanced tier.
Joe Powell
Lab
Kensington and Bayswater
Question
One weak point in protecting our parliamentary democracy from hostile state actors is money in politics. Does the Security Minister agree that this latest case shows that it is a priority to ensure that our electoral laws are robust enough that only funds that are clean and sourced entirely from within the UK fund our political parties?
Minister reply
The Minister agrees with his hon. Friend's point, noting that they have appointed Baroness Hodge as their new anti-corruption champion who will support their work on addressing dirty money in politics and ensuring robust electoral laws.
Paul Kohler
Lib Dem
Wimbledon
Question
In my constituency there are many Hongkongers deeply concerned about surveillance from Chinese agents. Can the Minister give my constituents any assurance that their legitimate fears are being addressed by the Government?
Minister reply
The Minister assures the hon. Member that the Government take seriously the kinds of interventions he refers to and through the defending democracy taskforce, they are looking carefully at the issue of transnational repression.
Josh Simons
Lab
Makerfield
Question
Can I ask the Minister about the integrity of our democracy? In particular, what steps is he taking to ensure the integrity of the processes and institutions of our political process, especially but not only with regard to China?
Minister reply
The Minister confirms that they are working closely on the defending democracy taskforce which seeks to address threats to the integrity of their democracy.
Bernard Jenkin
Con
Harwich and North Essex
Question
Just a few days ago, the head of MI5 talked about having to make “uncomfortable choices” and paring back counter-terrorism operations in order to deal with the huge rise in state threats. If security is the first priority of Government, will he undertake to ensure that MI5 and the security services as a whole have the resources they need?
Minister reply
The Minister assures the hon. Gentleman that the Home Secretary and he work closely with MI5 and colleagues across Government to ensure that they have the necessary resources.
Cardiff West
Question
I am grateful for the urgent question and thank the Minister for what he has said, in particular about the defending democracy taskforce. Can he assure me not only that the Government will do all they can to secure our national security but, with respect to individuals with known links to the Chinese Government considered a risk, that full investigations will be done?
Minister reply
The Minister assures his hon. Friend that the fullest of investigations will be conducted.
Chris Law
SNP
Dundee Central
Question
The United Front Work Department is said to have 40,000 members globally, and Mr Yang Tengbo is surely the tip of the iceberg in the UK. The department cultivates relationships with high-level figures extending influence to British nationals and those in all walks of society. What will be done to assess their numbers and what public awareness campaign will be made?
Minister reply
The Minister acknowledges the importance of public awareness and confirms that they are committed to implementing the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme which underlines why it is necessary.
John Slinger
Lab
Rugby
Question
Notwithstanding the somewhat chiding tone, does the Security Minister agree that it is possible to maintain a consistent and long-term relationship with China while taking robust measures to defend national interests?
Minister reply
The Minister agrees that maintaining a balance between cooperation economically and defending against threats is necessary.
Mark Pritchard
Con
The Wrekin
Question
Security Minister mentioned the breadth of the threat from Russia, China and Iran but did not mention North Korea. Is the Security Minister confident that the UK intelligence community has sufficient resources to manage the increased threat?
Minister reply
The Minister acknowledges the right hon. Gentleman's point about North Korea and confirms they will work with colleagues across Government to ensure security services have the necessary resources.
Lee Anderson
Reform
Ashfield
Question
Yang Tengbo is the alleged Chinese spy who has been stalking the corridors of power in our country, rubbing shoulders with royalty, Prime Ministers and business leaders, yet his name was withheld from the great British public. Does the Minister agree that his name was withheld only to avoid embarrassment for previous Prime Ministers and for business leaders, and that that was not in the best interests of the British public?
Minister reply
I am sure that the hon. Gentleman will acknowledge that I named H6. His initial anonymity was a result of a court order; it was not a UK Government decision.
Alec Shelbrooke
Con
Wetherby and Easingwold
Question
The west certainly learned a lesson about energy supplies and where they come from when Russia invaded. To build on what my right hon. Friend the Member for Chingford and Woodford Green said, I want to press the Minister on solar and renewables. The Government have an agenda to push this country quickly towards renewable energy, yet China manufactures and processes a lot of the materials that we need for it. Before we accelerate towards that goal, will the Minister undertake an assessment of the risk to our energy supply? That is a crucial piece of our national security.
Minister reply
I am genuinely grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for his reasonable and constructive points, which we will consider further. He will acknowledge that the Government must make difficult judgments about those matters, but I assure him that we will look at them with a clear-headed view of what is in our national interest, and in the end national security will always prevail.
Layla Moran
Lib Dem
Oxford West and Abingdon
Question
Does the Minister agree that it is not just the big schemes that need consideration, but the small ones too? Elite capture can happen at higher education and infrastructure level. Peking University HSBC business school in Oxford wants to expand. The local planning authority narrowly passed the proposal. I asked the previous Government to call it in, but just last week this Government approved the scheme. That is a mistake. The economic benefit will go primarily to the Chinese Communist party. Will the Minister’s Department ask the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government to look again at the scheme? What resilience is he offering local planning authorities on such matters?
Minister reply
The hon. Lady is right. It is not just about the bigger schemes; the smaller ones are important as well. I think what she refers to was essentially a planning matter, but I will look at it further. On matters relating to higher education, we work closely with colleagues in the Department for Education, and mechanisms are in place across Government so that when concerns are expressed, we will follow them up.
John Glen
Con
Salisbury
Question
I acknowledge the transformation in the security threat that this country faces, and I urge the Government to move forward as quickly as they can with the implementation of FIRS. However, I draw the Minister’s attention to the website of the US Department of the Treasury, which today gave a read-out on the seventh meeting of the financial working group between the US and the People’s Republic of China, and set out a memorandum of understanding arising from the group’s discussions in Nanjing. The Minister should do everything he can to ensure that we have a sophisticated relationship with China. As uncomfortable as that may be, in order to preserve global and financial stability, we need to maintain our relationship.
Minister reply
The right hon. Gentleman makes a very sensible point, as always. I have not yet looked at the US Treasury Department’s website, but I give him an undertaking that I will look at it and report back later today. He is right about the sophisticated relationship, as he describes it. As he knows government well, I can tell him that we take these matters incredibly seriously, and that the National Security Council provides the forum for decision making on these issues across Government.
Andrew Murrison
Con
South West Wiltshire
Question
The Government recently put on hold the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act, passed last year. Does he feel that that has helped or hindered the work of United Front in our universities, particularly our elite institutions?
Minister reply
The right hon. Gentleman makes a fair point, which I am very happy to discuss with him offline. I will look carefully at the suggestion he has made; I know that it is being considered by colleagues across Government, but let me take it away and I will come back to him.
David Chadwick
Lib Dem
Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe
Question
China is clearly trying to infiltrate all areas of UK society. Will the Minister outline the meetings that he is having with the Department for Business and Trade to ensure that the UK strengthens its foreign direct investment screening and cyber-defences, and focuses in particular on increased data transparency requirements, in order to become more economically resilient?
Minister reply
The hon. Member makes an important point. I can assure him that we are working collaboratively across Government, not only with colleagues in the Department for Business and Trade but with those in the Cabinet Office. He has mentioned cyber, which we take incredibly seriously.
Bradley Thomas
Con
Bromsgrove
Question
Can the Minister assure the House that Chinese investments in the UK are properly scrutinised, particularly those that may be used to acquire leverage over UK policy?
Minister reply
Yes, I can give that assurance.
Robin Swann
UUP
South Antrim
Question
The urgent question asked about the extent of the United Front Works Department’s operations in the United Kingdom. What is the Minister’s assessment of that department’s work with, or within, the devolved Administrations?
Minister reply
The hon. Member makes an important point. On the nature of the threat, I refer him to the annual threat lecture given by the director general of MI5 back in October. We work incredibly closely with all the devolved Administrations, and I hope at some point to visit the hon. Member’s part of the world.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Question
I thank the Minister for his answers. He will be aware that I have spoken on numerous occasions about the feelings of my constituents who are British passport holders of Chinese origin, and their impressions of the threats from the Chinese Communist party. Other hon. Members have also spoken on the subject. What the Minister has said is not surprising, but it remains concerning. Does he agree that inaction is not an option, and how can he give Chinese nationals who are British citizens assurance about their safety and security? I have had to make reports to the Police Service of Northern Ireland because I was concerned for these people’s safety while they live their life in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Minister reply
The hon. Gentleman has been consistent in raising this matter. Let me give him an absolute assurance that foreign intervention, wherever it comes from, is completely unacceptable, and this Government will use all tools at our disposal to combat it.
Shadow Comment
Iain Duncan Smith
Shadow Comment
The shadow criticised the lack of action against foreign interference, especially regarding China's United Front Work Department. He called for immediate implementation of FIRS to address security threats. The shadow questioned delays in naming China under the enhanced tier of FIRS due to pressure from business and government entities. He also raised concerns about a member of the royal family being exposed without proper scrutiny.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.