← Back to House of Commons Debates
Prisoner Releases in Error 2025-11-11
11 November 2025
Lead MP
David Lammy
Debate Type
General Debate
Tags
Justice & CourtsTaxationEmployment
Other Contributors: 43
At a Glance
David Lammy raised concerns about prisoner releases in error 2025-11-11 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
The Lord Chancellor acknowledged the release of Brahim Kaddour-Cherif, Hadush Kebatu, and other prisoners in error. He emphasised the need for stronger checks, better data management, and a radical overhaul of the release process. The Minister highlighted the challenges within the prison system due to understaffing and underfunding and committed to reducing releases in error through new initiatives such as a justice performance board, data reviews, and technological upgrades.
Robert Jenrick
Con
Newark
The shadow Justice Secretary criticised the current government's handling of prison releases in error. He pointed out that despite claims of robust checks, more prisoners were released incorrectly shortly after such assurances were given. He accused the Minister of incompetence and questioned his capability to handle the situation effectively.
Member
Name not specified
The public are being endangered as this circus rumbles on week after week, with no end in sight. The Justice Secretary needs to take responsibility for the confusion caused by Labour's early release scheme and the increase in prisoners accidentally released. The situation is worse than admitted; prisoners are being accidentally released nearly every other day, putting constituents at risk.
Lammy
Lab
Constituency not specified
The crisis was inherited from a previous government where 17 prisoners were released in error monthly. The issue is cross-party and due to resource shortages and prison officer cuts by the Conservatives. SDS40, introduced due to capacity issues, has caused some errors but checks are now in place.
Andy Slaughter
Lab
Hammersmith and Chiswick
Welcomes initiatives to deal with wrongful releases but warns that deeper malaise is symptomatic of a breakdown in order and discipline within the prison system. Proposes addressing drug culture, organised crime, and lack of education and work.
Jess Brown-Fuller
Lib Dem
Chichester
Critiques current security checks as inadequate and calls for biometric technology usage in confirming prisoner identity before release. Asks about training prison officers receive, duration Ministry of Justice knew about released prisoners, and immediate actions to prevent future releases.
Warinder Juss
Lab
Wolverhampton West
Agrees wrongful releases have caused distress among victims' families and acknowledges inheriting a chaotic prison system. Supports appropriate action being taken but recognises it will take time to resolve the issue.
Solihull West and Shirley
The Member emphasises that mistaken releases cost money due to police operations. He requests the Secretary of State to detail costs incurred by the police since the Government's tenure.
Tony Vaughan
Lab
Folkestone and Hythe
Vaughan seeks a commitment from the Deputy Prime Minister to remove all minimum custodial requirements for foreign offenders, aiming to expedite deportation after sentencing. He acknowledges previous Conservative efforts but calls for immediate action.
Ashley Fox
Con
Bridgwater
Fox questions whether new checks announced by the Justice Secretary prior to recent releases were effective or stringent enough, noting inconsistencies in implementation.
Sarah Russell
Lab
Congleton
Russell highlights workforce issues within prisons and calls for a 10-year plan similar to that of the NHS. She appreciates the Secretary of State's response but emphasises the need for long-term planning.
Tessa Munt
LD
Wells and Mendip Hills
Munt inquires whether the Lord Chancellor should have been more transparent about a potential mistaken release before making statements on public office accountability. She advocates for greater transparency to restore public confidence.
Andrew Pakes
Lab
Peterborough
Pakes expresses gratitude towards prison staff while criticising the Conservatives' legacy of underfunding and inefficiency in the prison system, urging investment in technology and solutions.
Andrew Mitchell
Con
Sutton Coldfield
Mitchell raises concerns over domestic abuse cases moving to open prisons prematurely, citing a specific example involving Natalie Queiroz. He seeks clarification on policy exclusions for such offenders.
Fleur Anderson
Lab
Putney
Anderson acknowledges increased investment in Wandsworth prison but expresses anxiety due to recent high-profile cases. She thanks the Justice Secretary for outlining measures like enhanced training and digital systems.
Caroline Johnson
Con
Sleaford and North Hykeham
Johnson questions the transparency of Government responses regarding the number of prisoners released in error still at large, emphasising adherence to ministerial codes of honesty and transparency.
Julie Minns
Lab
Carlisle
Minns urges assurance that this Government will implement findings from Dame Lynne Owens' investigation, aiming to restore public confidence in the prison system following years of increasing errors under previous administrations.
Torbay
Darling reports issues with security staff shortages and prisoner absconding incidents between courts and prisons. He seeks clarification on national occurrences and measures to prevent such failures.
Kate Hoey
Lab
Vauxhall
Mentioned the Magee review, highlighting that it was never implemented over 14 years of Conservative government. Emphasised cuts to Prison Service under Conservatives leading to inexperienced staff.
Julian Lewis
Con
New Forest East
Suggested a statement for prisoners due for release, informing them about potential wrongful releases and proposing penalties if they do not report it. Acknowledged by Mr Lammy but noted complexities in the current system.
Alex McIntyre
Lab
Gloucester
Referred to panto season's character Buttons, poking fun at the shadow Secretary of State for his desire for leadership. Blamed previous government for state of prisons.
Ben Obese-Jecty
Con
Huntingdon
Cited 284 accidental releases since July under current government, questioned assurances about no accidental releases from HMP Littlehey in constituency since Labour took office.
Catherine Fookes
Lab
Monmouthshire
Asked how we are tackling both building more prison places and releasing prisoners. Emphasised burden on clerks and officers calculating sentences and cited William Hague's criticism of previous government’s failure to build prisons or let people out.
Lincoln Jopp
Con
Spelthorne
Asked about Offenders (Day of Release from Detention) Act 2023 and whether it was devolved to prison governors, seeking clarification if ignored by governors.
Sam Rushworth
Lab
Bishop Auckland
Described chaotic justice system inherited from previous government causing 800 early releases. Highlighted support for victims and need to move away from paper-based systems.
Andrew Murrison
Con
South West Wiltshire
Asked about number of people wrongly detained and funding set aside for litigation. Criticised system's retention of prisoners when they should be released, alongside releases in error.
Alice Macdonald
Labour/Co-op
Norwich North
Asked for detail on support provided to victims in cases of wrongful release, emphasising importance of informing and supporting victims during such incidents.
James Wild
Con
North West Norfolk
Queried six-day delay in informing police about a sex offender's wrongful release from HMP Wandsworth, questioning priority given to public safety.
Derby North
Highlighted inherited weaknesses due to austerity and overcrowding. Emphasised need for rehabilitation through skills, education, and employment opportunities.
Defended the government’s actions, highlighted new programme initiatives such as housing people in military bases and increasing foreign nationals' returns to their countries. Acknowledged issues with wrongful releases but emphasised measures being taken.
Paul Waugh
Lab/Co-op
Rochdale
Thanked prison officer staff, criticised previous government's handling of prisoner releases and highlighted the need for victims to be at the heart of reforms.
Chris Vince
Lab/Co-op
Harlow
Agreed with comments made by colleagues, emphasised the need for better support upon release from prison and to ensure prisoners have somewhere to go after release.
Alison Griffiths
Con
Bognor Regis and Littlehampton
Expressed concern over a violent criminal released from Ford open prison in her constituency, requested information on other absconding prisoners.
Sarah Pochin
Reform
Runcorn and Helsby
Asked about crimes committed by wrongly released prisoners while at large.
Nick Timothy
Con
West Suffolk
Inquired about a foreign national offender who was mistakenly released from Ford open prison, requested details on entry into the country and whether he was an asylum seeker.
Alec Shelbrooke
Con
Wetherby and Easingwold
Asked when constituents would be able to say they no longer fear dangerous criminals being released onto the streets.
Luke Evans
Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Quoted PMQs, pressed for a guarantee that the Justice Secretary has control over issues related to prisoners released by mistake.
Iqbal Mohamed
Ind
Dewsbury and Batley
Paid tribute to probation staff, asked about timescales for addressing resource and system issues in prisons.
Bradley Thomas
Con
Bromsgrove
Asked if any prisoners have been accidentally released from Hewell Grange prison in Worcestershire.
Jack Rankin
Con
Windsor
Inquired about Justice Secretary's shopping for a suit after being informed of the release of Algerian sex offender Kaddour-Cherif.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Asked if the Secretary of State would commit to necessary changes, including updating data and technology in the present system for public safety and confidence.
Robert Jenrick
Con
Nottingham West
Mr Jenrick corrected the record, stating that the Justice Secretary had made a mistake by saying 17 prisoners a day were released in error under the last Conservative Government when it should be 17 prisoners a month.
Mr Speaker acknowledged and corrected the record, confirming that while the Justice Secretary initially said 17 prisoners a day, he meant to say 17 prisoners a month. He also noted that the actual figure was five prisoners per month.
David Lammy
Lab
Tottenham
Mr Lammy clarified his position and corrected the record by stating that the number of prisoners released in error under the previous Conservative Government was 17 a month, not a day as mistakenly reported earlier.
Government Response
The Lord Chancellor detailed steps taken to address releases in error, including setting up a justice performance board, requesting reviews on data adequacy, improving processes through an urgent warrant query unit and technological upgrades, accelerating system digitalisation with AI solutions, and simplifying release policies. The crisis was inherited from previous government cuts; addresses resource shortages and prison officer reductions under Conservatives. Introduces SDS40 due to capacity issues; acknowledges errors but implements double check processes. The Minister acknowledges past system inefficiencies and ongoing efforts, including the appointment of Dame Lynne Owens for a thorough review. He commits to technological advancements despite current paper-based challenges. The Minister emphasises data transparency and policy enhancements but also highlights inherited issues from previous administrations. Responded to various criticisms with commitments to digital technology investments, Sentencing Bill reforms simplifying sentencing system, and the importance of inter-agency cooperation to reduce human error. Defended government’s actions on housing people in military bases, increasing foreign nationals' returns, and acknowledged issues with wrongful releases. Emphasised measures being taken including new programme initiatives, funding for digital rapid response unit, urgent query process implementation and Sentencing Bill progress.
Shadow Response
Robert Jenrick
Shadow Response
The shadow Justice Secretary lambasted the Minister's handling of the situation as incompetent and questioned his ability to manage prison releases effectively. He noted that despite assurances of robust measures, more prisoners were released incorrectly shortly after such claims.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.