← Back to House of Commons Debates
Public Services Rural Areas 2025-01-22
22 January 2025
Lead MP
David Smith
Debate Type
Adjournment Debate
Tags
NHSTaxationHousingTransport
Other Contributors: 16
At a Glance
David Smith raised concerns about public services rural areas 2025-01-22 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
Colleagues across the House will be delighted to know that, as we have rattled through the business today, we get to have a four-hour debate, so I welcome interventions, and will welcome anybody else making a speech. It is genuinely a delight to lead my first Adjournment debate, especially one focusing on access to public services in rural areas. I am proud to be a rural Labour MP, so it is especially good to talk on this subject. In this speech, I will outline the domino effect by which a range of below-average rural public services interact and overlap to drag rural areas down, including North Northumberland. The key point is that we as a country need to value the people, landscapes, and produce of our countryside a great deal more. Successive Governments have not recognised the crucial role of rural communities in national flourishing. Rural Britain is often overlooked when it comes to public services, with council tax higher but spending lower compared to urban areas. Transport, education, healthcare, and connectivity issues are critical: distances travelled by bus service fell significantly; schools lack adequate resources for further education; elderly people face difficulties using their free bus passes across borders. I call for a publicly controlled bus system run for public service, not private profit, with an emphasis on accessibility, affordability, and simplicity.
Emma Foody
Lab/Co-op
Cramlington and Killingworth
The unreliability of local bus services means that children often miss out on their education as a consequence of poor public services in rural areas.
John Hayes
Con
South Holland and The Deepings
Public funding formulas should be sensitive to the particularities of rural areas such as Lincolnshire, and we need to re-dignify small towns and rural places by ensuring that the footprint of government is felt.
Sarah Dyke
LD
Glastonbury and Somerton
The settlement formula should consider rural deprivation alongside clustered deprivation to ensure that rural areas receive the services they deserve.
Joe Morris
Lab
Hexham
People in west Northumberland share the frustration about neglect by the Conservative administration at county hall. The provision of SEN transport is a major concern.
Henley and Thame
There is a need to review GPs’ core contracts to better incentivise them to set up in rural areas, where the ongoing need for a GP surgery is clear.
The centralisation of services under successive Governments seems particularly bad for rural areas and least advantaged people.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Rural communities face challenges with mental health, especially in farming communities due to isolation. He encourages people to reach out for help if they are struggling.
Luke Myer
Lab
Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland
Commented on the problem of addiction and substance abuse in rural communities, commending community-led initiatives such as Recovery Connections.
Dave Robertson
Lab
Lichfield
Fly-tipping in Litchfield led to road closures, affecting nine households' access to essential services and local businesses. Urgent action is needed from the police for prosecutions.
Adam Jogee
Lab
Newcastle-under-Lyme
Representing rural communities in Newcastle-under-Lyme, highlighting issues like transport, flooding, school finances, NHS pressures and local governance challenges. Urges support for rural communities through effective services.
Adam Jogee
Lab
Newcastle-under-Lyme
The MP urged the minister to provide clarity on the 'buy British and eat British' agenda.
Sean Woodcock
Lab
Banbury
He highlighted 14 years of under-investment in rural areas, setting up examples of community-led initiatives like affordable housing projects and local bus services to support the community despite challenges from elsewhere.
Matt Rodda
Lab
Reading Central
Expressed sympathy for residents facing cuts in bus services by Oxfordshire county council, supporting the initiative taken by local companies to set up their own bus service.
Chris Bloore
Lab
Redditch
The MP highlighted significant challenges in rural areas within his constituency and asked for a closer focus on such issues as the Government moves forward.
Daniel Zeichner
Lab
Cambridge
The hon. Member is trying to lure me into an unfunded spending commitment, but I assure him that we on this side of the House do not engage in such practices.
Inverness, Skye and West Ross
Will the Minister bear in mind the importance of community benefits from renewables?
Government Response
I welcome the debate on access to public services in rural areas. The Government recognises the crucial role of rural communities in national flourishing and acknowledges the particular challenges they face. We are committed to addressing funding disparities between urban and rural areas by reviewing local government funding formulas, ensuring that there is no penalty for living in a rural area. There are ongoing efforts to improve public transport services in rural regions, including considering publicly controlled bus systems run for public service with an emphasis on accessibility, affordability, and simplicity. We also aim to support educational initiatives such as the rebuilding of Berwick Academy to enhance further education opportunities and address deprivation. The Government is working towards creating a more equitable distribution of resources and recognising the unique needs of rural areas in delivering essential services. The Government acknowledges the challenges faced by rural areas. We have provided £1 billion increase in special educational needs funding which is excellent, and we are committed to ensuring that rural areas receive their fair share of it. Regarding healthcare, we recognise the importance of incentivising doctors and nurses to move into rural areas with incentives for GPs to see more patients and more of the same patients. We will introduce 700,000 more urgent dental appointments and look at options such as rotating shifts in Orkney to provide quality care. In terms of digital connectivity, we are committed to supporting ultra-rural communities through Great British Energy and developing ways to support Project Gigabit so that ultra-rural areas benefit from these upgrades. We will continue to work on addressing the issues of social care, public health, mental health pressures due to isolation, and addiction in rural communities. The Government acknowledges the importance of public services in rural areas and is committed to supporting them across various Departments. DEFRA works closely with other Ministries to address specific issues such as fly-tipping, flooding, transport infrastructure, and healthcare access. The Minister commits to continue championing rural communities' needs through policy initiatives and cross-Government collaboration. The minister acknowledged the problems raised by MPs, expressing sympathy towards residents affected by criminal activities like fly-tipping. He commended community-led initiatives and emphasised the government's commitment to supporting buying British products and promoting housing through community land trusts. The Minister also noted the productivity gap between the rural economy and national average and highlighted opportunities for growth in rural areas. The Government are absolutely committed to improving the quality of life for everyone living and working in rural areas, so that we can make a real impact on their everyday lives. We have announced a series of planning reforms to get Britain building, removed the de facto ban on onshore wind, established a national wealth fund, announced a pensions review to unlock growth, boosted investment, delivered savings for pensioners, launched Skills England, and taken the first steps to create Great British Energy. The Government recognise the specific challenges facing rural communities and economies, including issues such as affordable housing, digital access, transport, and energy costs. We are committed to ensuring that all populated areas have higher-quality stand-alone 5G access by 2030 and nationwide gigabit coverage by 2030. Additionally, we will reform planning laws so that we can build the homes rural communities need while protecting green spaces and the natural environment. We are making significant new funding available for local government in 2025-26, which we think will help with some of the wider issues. There is £1.3 billion of new funding in the local government financial settlement, with £600 million to support the most deprived areas, including in shire districts, through the new recovery grant. There is also £233 million of additional funding for homelessness services.
There is a guarantee that no local authority will see a reduction in its core spending power in 2025-26 after taking account of any increase in council tax levels. We believe this will provide the protections required for all authorities, including district councils, to sustain their services between years. Taking into account both the money allocated to councils through the settlement and the extended producer responsibility guarantee, every council will have more to spend on planning and social care services in 2025-26 than in 2024-25. For almost all authorities, we expect that to be a real-terms increase. We are also providing a flat cash funding floor after council tax increases, which means that every council will receive as much in core spending power next year as they received this year, if not more.
This Government recognise the importance of providing accessible, high-quality services across rural communities, and we will continue to do everything in our power to ensure that they are delivered effectively.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.