Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Business of the House 2025-03-13

13 March 2025 · 57 other contributors

Opened by Jesse Norman Con Hereford and South Herefordshire

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Jesse Norman raised concerns about business of the house 2025-03-13 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • The debate criticises the Government's handling of economic policies.
  • Jesse Norman highlights negative impacts on energy and defence sectors.
  • Concerns raised about rural areas being disproportionately affected by national insurance hikes.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Jesse Norman Con Hereford and South Herefordshire

The debate criticises the Government's handling of economic policies, highlighting the Prime Minister's inability to manage the economy effectively. Jesse Norman emphasises that despite initial claims of no tax rises or increased borrowing, recent events have proven otherwise, leading to negative impacts on sectors such as energy and defence. He raises concerns about rural areas being disproportionately affected by national insurance hikes and compulsory purchase powers affecting farmland.

Other contributors (57)
  • Lucy Powell Lab Wirral South

    Lucy Powell responds to Jesse Norman's critique, acknowledging the difficult decisions taken by her Government due to economic challenges. She defends the increase in farming budget and new support schemes for farmers, criticising opposition claims as misinformation. Powell highlights legislative achievements of the current Government including boosting public services and reforming the state.

  • Cat Eccles Lab Stourbridge

    Eccles raises concerns about the effects of Primodos, a hormone-based pregnancy test from the 1960s and 70s linked to severe birth defects in children. She calls for a full debate on this issue or a public inquiry.

  • Marie Goldman LD Chelmsford

    Discussed the importance of ensuring children have access to healthy and nutritious food. Highlighted that in government, her party introduced universal free school meals for infants. Proposed increasing the after-tax threshold for free school meals to £20,000 a year, expanding eligibility to 900,000 more children.

  • Rachel Hopkins Lab Luton South and South Bedfordshire

    Called for a debate on improving accessibility at Luton station through the Government’s Great British Railways plan. Mentioned delays in Network Rail's Access for All programme which has led to frustration among disabled constituents.

  • Bob Blackman Con Harrow East

    Announced various upcoming debates on topics such as digital platforms' impact on democracy, access to sport and physical education, drugs prevention, and waste incinerators. Also highlighted the celebration of Purim and Holi.

  • Laura Kyrke-Smith Lab Aylesbury

    Recognised the work of Amy Scullard in running a peer support group for parents with mental health issues. Highlighted the importance of perinatal mental health services.

  • Julian Lewis Con New Forest East

    Asked for an urgent statement on the Government's decision to permanently decommission shale gas facilities, raising concerns about potential future emergencies needing these resources.

  • Phil Brickell Lab Bolton West

    Expressed concern over delays in DBS checks impacting job offers for public service roles. Requested a debate to address this issue and mentioned hardship escalation requests as a possible solution.

  • Alistair Carmichael LD Orkney and Shetland

    Requested an early debate on the ending of radio teleswitch, which is crucial for many people relying on electric heating. Mentioned previous debates in December and a roundtable meeting promising updates but no action yet.

  • Liz Twist Lab Blaydon and Consett

    Expressed concern over the reduced opening hours of the Consett Empire, a cultural centre crucial for local arts access and combating loneliness. Requested a debate to explore ways to ensure such venues thrive.

  • Iain Stewart Con Milton

    Expressed concern about the Department for Work and Pensions backlog of more than 30,000 pension credit claims. Cited assurances from the Minister in October that extra staff would be deployed but noted the continued presence of a significant backlog despite additional staffing.

  • Responded to concerns about the pension credit backlog, noting an 81% increase in claims and deployment of additional staff. Emphasised that successful applications would be backdated for applicants. Acknowledged challenges faced by Parkinson’s PIP assessors and committed to keeping Members updated on training and understanding necessary for these assessments.

  • Navendu Mishra Lab Stockport

    Celebrated Holi and highlighted the issue of Parkinson's disease, requesting a debate on supporting people with Parkinson’s and other degenerative conditions due to inadequate support from PIP assessors. Commended Parkinson's UK for their work.

  • Chris Law SNP Dundee Central

    Expressed concern about the financial difficulties faced by Dundee University due to nearly £3 million of employer national insurance contributions, requesting a Treasury Minister statement on this issue and potential pause for establishments in serious financial difficulties.

  • Jo Platt Lab/Co-op Leigh and Atherton

    Called attention to the Canal & River Trust’s management of 2,000 miles of waterway, including nearly 500 miles in the north-west. Highlighted confusion about ownership and funding difficulties faced by the trust and requested a debate on the importance of canals as part of our heritage.

  • John Glen Con Salisbury

    Requested a statement from a Health Minister regarding the future of Porton Down facility in his constituency after its transition through multiple health-related agencies. Mentioned persistent applications for an Adjournment debate on this topic.

  • Chris Vince Lab/Co-op Harlow

    Celebrated Young Carers Action Day and congratulated a constituent, Danielle, for her poetry prize in the Show Racism the Red Card competition. Highlighted the importance of creative writing in breaking down barriers and challenging division.

  • Martin Vickers Con Brigg and Immingham

    Called for a debate on the impact of shipping on the UK economy, particularly focusing on his constituency's economic ties to this sector. Mentioned recent North Sea incidents during a meeting with the UK Chamber of Shipping.

  • Allison Gardner Lab Stoke-on-Trent South

    Discussed challenges faced by constituents in obtaining necessary wheelchairs, advocating for NHS England to take an active role in ensuring adequate wheelchair services and resources are prioritised. Requested a debate on these challenges.

  • Tessa Munt LD Wells and Mendip Hills

    Raised concerns about delays in visa processing for a constituent, Jennifer, seeking indefinite leave to remain. Highlighted the financial and work-related uncertainties this has caused. Requested assistance from the Home Office to expedite the process.

  • Emma Foody Lab/Co-op Cramlington and Killingworth

    Discussed local survey results regarding antisocial behaviour and off-road bikes in her constituency. Emphasised support for measures in the Crime and Policing Bill to tackle these issues, requesting a debate on ensuring police have necessary powers and resources.

  • John Doe Con Huntingdon

    Supports the funding for Huntingdon High Street resurfacing, encourages more steps towards regeneration. Requests time to debate high street regeneration.

  • Supports funding for Huntington High Street and praises BID teams. Promises support for future regeneration efforts. Acknowledges the role of pubs in community hubs like the Royal Oak in Wolverhampton West. Defends government action on Northern Ireland justice issues, suggesting reform is needed. Commits to robust parliamentary scrutiny of trade deals. Praises foster carers and raises concerns about fostering education. Supports ovarian cancer awareness initiatives. Urges the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to restart cross-party talks on social care. Encourages MP engagement with constituents regarding their role in Parliament. Promises a debate on the food and drink industry. Emphasises capital investment in school buildings.

  • Warinder Juss Lab Wolverhampton West

    Congratulates Royal Oak pub for community fundraising efforts, requests Leader of the House to visit and acknowledge its contribution to local communities.

  • Carla Lockhart DUP Upper Bann

    Critiques current justice system in Northern Ireland as one-sided and demands a debate on historical truth and legacy issues from the Troubles era.

  • Martin Rhodes Lab Glasgow North

    Asks for adequate time to discuss trade deals with Gulf Co-operation Council, Israel, India, etc., which have implications for UK economy, environment, and global trade.

  • Bradley Thomas Con Bromsgrove

    Praises foster carers in his constituency, suggests fostering education inclusion in school curricula to reduce stigma around different family structures.

  • Terry Jermy Lab South West Norfolk

    Urges for debate on ovarian cancer awareness and asks Leader of the House to attend an event next week.

  • Ellie Chowns Green North Herefordshire

    Requests restarting cross-party talks on social care, criticises last-minute cancellation of such talks.

  • Claire Hughes Lab Bangor Aberconwy

    Engages with school pupils and raises questions about her role as an MP. Asks for a message to be sent to Welsh-medium schools during Your Vote Week.

  • Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross

    Requests debate on UK's food and drink industry's value in exports and tourism, emphasising local employment and export benefits.

  • Danny Beales Lab Uxbridge and South Ruislip

    Highlights poor condition of school buildings in his constituency and calls for capital investment in schools, referencing the Building Schools for the Future programme by the previous Labour government.

  • John Calley Con Worth Valley

    Expresses concern over the Walshaw moor wind farm, which is a large development in protected peatland. Asks for a debate on the importance of raising local concerns about such developments and criticism towards Labour's removal of the moratorium.

  • Lucy Powell Lab MP

    Defends Labour's lifting of the moratorium on wind farm developments, highlighting their importance for energy security, jobs, and lower bills. Announces the Planning and Infrastructure Bill to ensure incentives for those affected by new infrastructure.

  • Adam Jogee Lab Newcastle-under-Lyme

    Raises the issue of mental health support for children with autism in his constituency, urging a debate on improving such services specifically for young people under 18.

  • Alison Bennett LD Mid Sussex

    Discusses the community equipment services sector and its importance in aiding individuals to live independently outside hospital. Requests a debate on the impact of rising national insurance contributions on this sector.

  • Steve Race Lab Exeter

    Praises his vote for the Employment Rights Bill which bans fire and rehire tactics, but criticises Devon County Council's use of these tactics. Asks for a debate to address this issue.

  • John Lamont Con Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk

    Raises opposition among residents in the Scottish Borders to plans by ScottishPower Energy Networks to build pylons through their area. Requests the Leader of the House to engage with Ofgem on this matter.

  • Kevin McKenna Lab Sittingbourne and Sheppey

    Discusses barriers faced by children on the Isle of Sheppey in accessing secondary school places due to distance from mainland. Asks for a debate on the allocation system for these schools.

  • Llinos Medi PC Ynys Môn

    Requests a debate on nuclear energy developments at Wylfa, questioning whether this Government remain committed to such projects despite changes in national policy statements.

  • Lee Pitcher Lab Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme

    Announces efforts to reconnect his communities through a proposed super-loop bus service. Congratulates Hornsby Travel for its 110th anniversary and seeks support in ensuring transport links for constituents.

  • Wera Hobhouse LD Bath

    Raises concerns about social housing repair funding falling below inflation levels, requesting a debate on how to protect tenants while addressing the social housing crisis.

  • Alex Baker Lab Aldershot

    Congratulates Union Yard in Aldershot for opening and asks for support to facilitate more retail opportunities for local creative businesses. Requests a debate on this issue.

  • Euan Stainbank Lab Falkirk

    Raises the case of Zoe, who has had difficulty obtaining diagnoses and treatment for POTS due to lack of national guidelines or clinical pathways. Asks for a debate to discuss creating such guidelines.

  • Zoe Not specified in the text

    Concerned about NHS POTS services in Scotland under Scottish Government.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Expresses concern over human rights violations against Kabyle Berber minority in Algeria, including arbitrary arrests and restrictions on religious freedom. Urges the Foreign Secretary to make a statement on this matter urgently.

  • Reassures Jim Shannon that British ambassador regularly raises concerns with Algerian counterparts.

  • Chris Bloore Lab Redditch

    Pays tribute to Madge Tillsley MBE, a trailblazing councillor and first black mayor in Worcestershire. Requests Leader of the House to send condolences to her family.

  • Supports Chris Bloore's tribute and sends condolences to Madge Tillsley’s family.

  • Amanda Hack Lab North West Leicestershire

    Thankful for the Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland resilience forum exercise 'Operation Mercury' testing emergency response. Requests Leader of the House to join in thanking local emergency services.

  • Fully supports Amanda Hack's appreciation towards the work done by emergency services.

  • Jim Dickson Lab Dartford

    Concerned about methanol poisoning deaths in Laos and requests a debate on increasing awareness of risks associated with methanol poisoning.

  • Acknowledges the tragic case, updates travel advice, and continues to press for investigation to prevent future incidents. Sends best wishes to Simone’s family.

  • Katrina Murray Lab Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch

    Concerned about potential closure of Cumbernauld theatre due to funding cut by Creative Scotland, requests debate on the importance of local theatres in cultural access.

  • Supports Katrina Murray's position but points out that the matter is devolved and requires action from Scottish Government.

  • Joe Powell Lab Kensington and Bayswater

    Pays tribute to Almanaar Muslim cultural centre for its pivotal role after Grenfell and during the pandemic, wishing all Muslims a blessed Ramadan.

  • Joins Joe Powell in paying tribute to Almanaar Muslim cultural centre's work post-Grenfell tragedy and wishes all Muslims a blessed Ramadan.

Government Response

Responded to multiple issues including free school meal eligibility, rail accessibility challenges, mental health support groups, DBS delays, the end of radio teleswitch, and cultural venue concerns. Emphasised government commitments to child poverty reduction, free breakfast clubs, railway improvements, perinatal mental health services, and addressing constituent-specific issues. Responded to various concerns including pension credit backlog, Parkinson’s PIP assessments, university funding challenges, Canal & River Trust difficulties, Porton Down facility future, young carers recognition, shipping sector importance, wheelchair provision issues, visa processing delays, and antisocial behaviour measures. Committed to updating Members on these topics. Lucy Powell (Labour Party) responded to various queries with policy defences, funding announcements in bills such as the Planning and Infrastructure Bill and Renters’ Rights Bill, and highlighted ongoing efforts to support communities affected by energy infrastructure developments.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy