Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

International Men’s Day

21 November 2024 · 27 other contributors

Opened by Sam Rushworth Lab Bishop Auckland

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Sam Rushworth raised concerns about international men’s day in the House of Commons. Other MPs contributed to the debate.

Key points

  • Moves a debate in the House of Commons to consider International Men's Day
  • Highlights issues affecting boys' and men's health and wellbeing
  • Emphasises that gender inequality harms everyone

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Sam Rushworth Lab Bishop Auckland

Moves a debate in the House of Commons to consider International Men’s Day, highlighting issues affecting boys' and men's health and wellbeing. He emphasises that gender inequality harms everyone and provides statistics showing higher rates of premature death, alcohol addiction, homelessness, suicide, imprisonment, and violent crime among men compared to women.

Other contributors (27)
  • Sam Rushworth Lab Bishop Auckland

    Opens the debate by acknowledging his lack of prior experience in discussing issues specific to boys' and men's health. He emphasises the importance of recognising gender inequality as a problem affecting everyone, not just women. He cites concerning statistics regarding premature death, alcohol addiction, homelessness, suicide, imprisonment, and violent crime among men.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Intervenes to highlight the high number of suicides among young men under 18 in Northern Ireland over the past five years. He notes that almost 5,000 young men have committed suicide, which is concerning.

  • Chris McDonald Lab Stockton North

    Compliments Sam Rushworth on his initiative and questions whether young men are vulnerable to negative online role models. He suggests that older men should provide positive role models for younger men to talk about issues.

  • Dawn Butler Lab Brent East

    Congratulates Sam Rushworth on securing the debate and criticises the lack of Conservative presence in the Chamber. She highlights various charities working with men and boys, including barbers who encourage young customers to talk about issues such as timekeeping. She provides statistics on prostate cancer deaths and male suicide rates. Dawn Butler also discusses the growing number of involuntary celibates (incels) and their negative impact on society.

  • Jerome Mayhew Con Broadland and Fakenham

    I rise to balance the Benches and stand up for men—Members on the Government Benches cannot have it all their own way. I recently visited the Aylsham men’s shed, about two weeks ago, which welcomes women as well as men. This debate has helped me reflect on what it means to be a man. Men are less good at and prepared to focus on and invest time in the soft relationships that go into making a personal community. I have learned a lot from this debate and am grateful for the Backbench Business Committee and the hon. Member for Bishop Auckland (Sam Rushworth) for organising it. The Aylsham community shed is in a shared space in the high school, which brings challenges, but they are welcoming organisations that provide support to men of all ages. While these organisations rely on their communities for funding and accommodation, I encourage everyone to support them.

  • Calvin Bailey Lab Leyton and Wanstead

    I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Bishop Auckland (Sam Rushworth) on securing this debate. Prostate cancer impacts one in eight men, with early diagnosis crucial for survival rates. Geographically, late diagnosis is concentrated in some areas such as Scotland and the north-east of England, and black men are 2.5 times more likely to die from prostate cancer than white men due to lower access to diagnosis. We need a Government plan to improve screening and reduce disproportionate impacts for black men. I also discuss the threat created by far-right online influencers who weaponise masculinity, leading to radicalisation including misogyny, racism and homophobia among young men. We should recognise this threat and defend our young people from it.

  • Danny Chambers Lib Dem Winchester

    The speaker highlighted several issues affecting men, including mental health, suicide rates, homelessness, and farming. He emphasised that men are three times more likely than women to die by suicide and discussed the importance of organisations like Emmaus Hampshire, Winchester Beacon, Trinity Winchester, Farming Community Network, and LooseHeadz in addressing these problems. Chambers also acknowledged the role of women in encouraging men to seek help for health issues and called for more research into endometriosis.

  • Mims Davies Con East Grinstead and Uckfield

    I associate myself with the tributes paid to Lord Prescott. In my 10 years in this House, men have made a significant difference through their work in constituencies and surgeries. I thank Sam Rushworth for securing this debate on behalf of His Majesty’s official Opposition. It is an opportunity to support our menfolk—dads, brothers, husbands, sons, grandsons, uncles, grandads, father figures, male friends, and allies. ManKind supports male victims of domestic violence; MANUP focuses on male mental health; CALM supports men's mental health as well as prostate and testicular cancers. Groups like the Uckfield men’s shed and Burgess Hill men’s shed make a big difference in communities.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    He made an intervention about the impact of male suicide, especially that of young men.

  • Dawn Butler Lab Brent East

    She talked about rights not being a zero-sum game and the importance of places like barbershops for conversation.

  • Jerome Mayhew Con Broadland and Fakenham

    He paid tribute to the environment created by Men’s Sheds and discussed the importance of groups in his community.

  • Bailey Lab Leyton and Wanstead

    He talked about men’s health matters, the bravery of men talking about emotion, and tackling transphobia. Social media challenges are also addressed.

  • Alex Sobel Green Leeds Central and Headingley

    He discussed the men who have stepped up in Ukraine, the work during war and sacrifices made, as well as the challenges of social media and tackling transphobia.

  • Lola McEvoy Lab Darlington

    She spoke about true equality and valuing the community by the action of men.

  • John Slinger Con Rugby

    He talked about tackling male stereotypes.

  • Peter Swallow Tories Bracknell

    He made a thoughtful speech about life as a young gay man and the importance of diversity in expectations.

  • Chambers Lib Dem Winchester

    He pointed out issues like farmers and loneliness, gambling addiction, substance abuse, divorce, bereavement, career issues, money worries, job losses, body image, and the need for spaces to talk.

  • Nia Griffith Lab Llanelli

    Celebrated International Men’s Day and discussed the positive contributions men make. Acknowledged Lord Prescott's tireless campaigning on issues like worker’s rights and mental health. Noted a constructive debate focusing on health, suicide, crime, education, entertainment, and the influence of social media. Emphasised the need for more support services, especially for young men facing body image pressures and targeted by extremists. Highlighted the importance of mental health care access in schools and recruitment of new mental health workers. Mentioned various organisations working on prostate cancer awareness and suicide prevention, like Second Step’s Hope Project in Bristol. Discussed the Government's commitment to reducing health inequalities and tackling addictions through increased funding for drug and alcohol treatment and recovery services.

  • Dawn Butler Lab Brent East

    Mentioned prostate cancer awareness and discussed the harmful subculture of incel, advocating against misogyny and extremism targeting young men. Highlighted the need for positive role models to combat negative social pressures.

  • Jerome Mayhew Con Broadland and Fakenham

    Discussed volunteer groups in his constituency, such as Aylsham Men's Shed, emphasising their importance in providing support for men’s health and wellbeing.

  • Bailey Lab Leyton and Wanstead

    Focussed on young men who are targeted by extremists with misogynistic content. Advocated for restoring hope among youth and helping them achieve their goals through positive role models and mental health support.

  • Alex Sobel Lab Leeds Central and Headingley

    Focused on trans men and the need to address transphobia, underlining the Government's commitment to ensuring trans people receive adequate care in NHS services. Mentioned the engagement with LGBT+ health advisers.

  • Lola McEvoy Lab Darlington

    Discussed the importance of men talking about their mental and physical health needs from paternity leave to veteran support, highlighting various services available for different age groups.

  • John Slinger Con Rugby

    Tackled stereotypes by citing examples like the inclusion of choirs in rugby teams. Highlighted suicide prevention initiatives and mental health support in his constituency, emphasising the importance of positive male role models.

  • Peter Swallow Lab Bracknell

    Talked about stereotypes and their pressure on men’s lives, focusing on suicide prevention and mental health services, encouraging more open dialogue about these issues.

  • Chambers Lib Dem Winchester

    As a vet, advised the importance of regular health checks for farmers who are now opening up about their health. Emphasised prostate cancer awareness and urged men to get checked regularly.

  • Sam Rushworth Lab Bishop Auckland

    Expressed gratitude for the respectful debate, acknowledged contributions from other Members on voluntary work and charities in their communities. Noted the importance of social emotional learning on the curriculum and positive masculinity in classrooms. Emphasised the significance of strengthening the charity sector and called for a mental health Minister.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy