Housing: Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly

Opened the debate

The MP for St Ives raised serious concerns about the lack of affordable housing in Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly. He highlighted severe issues such as high housing need, low social housing stock, and increasing demand for second homes and holiday lets. Andrew George emphasised the challenges faced by local charities trying to deliver affordable homes due to inflated land values and developers’ reluctance. He proposed devolving powers to set targets aimed at reducing need rather than just boosting supply. Additionally, he discussed the effectiveness of rural exception sites in delivering affordable housing but warned against cross-subsidy practices. The MP also addressed construction industry inflation and the impact on local communities, urging for an increase in funding for Homes England's programme. He further highlighted housing injustices due to tax loopholes benefiting holiday homeowners at the expense of affordable home delivery.

Government Response

The Minister acknowledged the severity of the housing crisis in Cornwall and Isles of Scilly, addressing concerns about house price-to-earnings ratios, shrinking private rental sectors, and growing social housing waiting lists. He emphasised the importance of increasing home supply across England and the need for mandatory housing targets to boost supply. The Minister also addressed rural exception sites and the need for robust support in rural areas while considering measures to better support affordable housing developments. He further committed to addressing second homes and short-term lets, recognising their detrimental impact on local communities. Matthew Pennycook concluded by expressing his commitment to working closely with Cornish Members to ensure first homes for all local people.