Adequacy of the Scotland Act 1998

Opened the debate

Three years ago, David Davis raised concerns about the unlawful investigation by the Scottish Government against Alex Salmond. He highlighted that a committee appointed by Holyrood was ineffective due to limited powers of investigation and interference from the Scottish Government. Mr Salmond has been acquitted, but issues remain unresolved regarding the fairness and legality of the process. The debate emphasised potential perjury, collusion, and obstruction by senior figures in the SNP, affecting the rule of law in Scotland. Davis urged for stronger investigatory powers for the Scottish Parliament, independent decisions on prosecutions, and a separation of roles within the Crown Office to prevent conflicts of interest.

Government Response

Kirsty McNeill welcomed the debate and celebrated the Scotland Act 1998, marking 25 years since the establishment of the Scottish Parliament. She emphasised the need for cross-party collaboration to drive progress, focusing on resetting relationships between Westminster and Holyrood. The Minister committed to enhancing free speech protections for Members in devolved legislatures, aligning them with those enjoyed by MPs at Westminster. McNeill highlighted ongoing legal proceedings involving Mr Salmond and the Scottish Government, emphasising that scrutiny of the Scottish Government remains a matter for the Scottish Parliament. She concluded by affirming Labour’s commitment to delivering change for Scotland through initiatives like making it the home of Great British Energy, establishing a national wealth fund, and implementing a new deal for working people.