Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Proposed British Jewish History Month

11 January 2024 · 20 other contributors

Opened by Nickie Aiken Con City of London and Westminster, North

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Nickie Aiken raised concerns about proposed british jewish history month in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Proposes the creation of a British Jewish History Month to recognise their contributions to various fields.
  • Acknowledge the small population size but highlight significant impact in business, science, arts, and politics.
  • Minister supports the initiative and expresses willingness to work with the community.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Nickie Aiken Con City of London and Westminster, North

Proposes the creation of a British Jewish History Month to recognise the contributions of British Jews to all walks of life in this country. Acknowledges the small population size but highlights their significant impact in business, science, arts, and politics. Emphasises the need for such recognition due to rising antisemitism.

Other contributors (20)
  • Alex Sobel Lab Co-op Leeds Central

    Supports the motion by highlighting contributions from Labour MPs as well, mentioning Manny Shinwell who served in government and at age 101. Acknowledges the broad political representation of British Jews.

  • Fabian Hamilton Lab Leeds North East

    It is a privilege to speak in this debate, which was opened so well by the hon. Member for Cities of London and Westminster. I thank her and her colleagues for securing the debate. I am proud to represent the constituency with the largest Jewish population in Yorkshire, contributing significantly to our city’s culture, economy and society. The Jewish community has a fantastic history, especially regarding their frontline role against fascism and continued political engagement. In Leeds, there are Reform and Orthodox synagogues, kosher bakeries, butchers, and various support services provided by organisations like the Leeds Jewish Welfare Board. Given the current cost of living crisis, these efforts are crucial today. I also reflect on Sheila Saunders’s legacy in founding Leeds Jewish Women’s Aid for those affected by domestic abuse and sexual violence. My father’s journey from a persecuted Jew to a naturalised British citizen exemplifies this history. Lastly, I pay tribute to holocaust survivors like Trude Silman, Arek Hersh, and Iby Knill who contribute to our collective knowledge.

  • Peter Bottomley Con Birmingham Yardley

    It is an honour to follow the hon. Member for Leeds North East, Fabian Hamilton. He reminds me of the book about Friedrich Engels by Tristram Hunt and Hadley Freeman's book on family survival in London. What differentiates Jewish history from others is the continuous questioning 'Why do they keep picking on us?'. There are 16 million Jews worldwide, with around a quarter-million here, contributing magnificently. My hon. Friend Nickie Aiken introduced this debate, and I commend Esther Rantzen for her work. Notably, it's not just significant people but everyday individuals who make contributions in various fields. I support the national holocaust memorial commission and learning centre proposals as they educate about our shared history. Our future is together if we learn from each other’s traditions. At Sir Simon Milton’s funeral, a member of the Community Security Trust thanked me for my presence, reflecting the importance of mutual defence.

  • Ian Paisley Jnr DUP North Antrim

    Emphasises the necessity of a Jewish history month to promote understanding and historical knowledge, citing examples such as the Herzog family's contributions across Ireland and Belfast. He highlights the rich tapestry of heritage that includes Hebrew traditions and their significant role in local history.

  • Andrew Percy Con Brigg and Goole

    Supports the proposal for a Jewish history month, highlighting the complex but significant historical relationship between Jews and Yorkshire. Discusses the transmigration through Hull at the end of the 19th century and the substantial impact made by Jewish individuals in public life in Hull.

  • Christine Jardine Lib Dem Edinburgh West

    Acknowledges the rich cultural contributions of the Jewish community beyond antisemitism, including literary figures like Muriel Spark and political figures such as Malcolm Rifkind. Discusses historical milestones in Scotland's Jewish communities and emphasises the need to celebrate this history while combating antisemitism.

  • Michael Ellis Con New Forest East

    I emphasised the importance of Jewish history, highlighting hope in the face of antisemitism. I referenced historical examples and modern heroes who have stood against hate and for peace, such as Youssef Ziadna and Rami from Israel. I also mentioned positive developments like the Abraham accords and praised political leaders for standing up against dissent.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    I acknowledged the rich Jewish heritage in Northern Ireland, mentioning guided tours of Belfast with Jewish connections, the interactive online Jewish heritage map of Northern Ireland, and the historical significance of McGill’s farm. I advocated for a Jewish history month to increase awareness and challenge antisemitic stereotypes, emphasising the intrinsic link between the Jewish community and British culture.

  • Charlotte Nichols Lab Warrington North

    Stressed the importance of recognising a broader spectrum of Jewish contributions beyond antisemitism and Israel, including cultural aspects like wrestling. Cited historical figures such as Al Lipman and contemporary stars like Noam Dar to illustrate diverse achievements within British Jewry. Emphasised the potential for a Jewish history month to educate on varied Jewish contributions.

  • Greg Smith Con Mid Buckinghamshire

    I celebrate the Jewish population in my constituency, which has grown by 7% between 2011 and 2021. However, there is a sense of fear and insecurity among Jews due to antisemitism, including hate speech on social media. I support the call for a Jewish history month to highlight their contributions to British society.

  • Robin Millar Con Aberconwy

    I thank Nickie Aiken for securing this debate and acknowledge the significant contribution of the Jewish community in Aberconwy. Despite historical challenges, including Edward I's expulsion of Jews in 1290, the Jewish population has thrived economically and culturally since the Victorian era. Recent examples include the first Jewish mayor in Aberconwy elected in 1978 and the care of Conwy battlements handed to a Jewish constable in 2012. I support celebrating this history as it enriches our national identity.

  • Kirsten Oswald Lab East Renfrewshire

    I congratulate the hon. Member for Cities of London and Westminster on securing the debate and on the strength of her opening speech. I love where I live, which is home to people of all faiths, including a vibrant Muslim community, various Christian congregations, significant Sikh and Hindu communities, Baha’i followers, and most Jews living in Scotland. We should celebrate the diversity that makes us who we are. The Jewish community in East Renfrewshire has been present since the 1700s and made significant contributions to medicine, law, education, and business. I mentioned the work of Rabbi Pete Tobias, Ernest Levy, Rabbi Moshe Rubin, Henry Wuga, Brigadier Monty Cowen, Evie Yedd, Cosgrove Care, Jewish Care, the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities, the Glasgow Jewish Representative Council, and other groups for their cross-community and cross-faith dialogue. These organisations have been vital in supporting the community and encouraging discussion.

  • Liz Twist Lab Blaydon and Consett

    I thank the hon. Member for Cities of London and Westminster for securing this debate, which has been hugely interesting. I recognise the rich contribution of the Jewish community across British civil society despite historical discrimination such as the persecution in 1190 and expulsion under Edward I. In Gateshead, there is a large Charedi community with one of the largest yeshivas outside Israel. Jewish communities have contributed to trade unions, communal organisations, and charitable work. Jami provides mental health support for the Jewish community and works in partnership with other communities. Jewish Women’s Aid offers specialist support to Jewish women affected by domestic abuse. The Community Security Trust has recorded over 2000 antisemitic incidents since October. We must combat hate crime through education about the holocaust and support a permanent memorial and learning centre. Labour supports British Jewish history month and works with Jewish community organisations on community cohesion.

  • Lee Rowley Con Rotherham

    Responded on behalf of the Government, supporting the idea of a British Jewish history month. Acknowledged the significant contributions made by British Jews across various fields such as arts, law, medicine, media, finance, charity sector, retail and sports. Highlighted historical figures like Benjamin Disraeli, Ludwig Guttmann, Lucian Freud, and Siegfried Sassoon among others.

  • Fabian Hamilton Lab Leeds North East

    Contributed to the debate by discussing the history of the Jewish community in Britain. Emphasised the importance of recognising their contributions and overcoming historical challenges.

  • Peter Bottomley Con Worthing West

    Talked about the significant role of the Jewish community in shaping British society, including challenging instances such as antisemitism. Emphasised the importance of inter-faith dialogue and understanding.

  • Jim Shannon UUP Strangford

    Acknowledged the contributions of the Jewish community in various parts of the Union, highlighting the diversity within the community and its long-standing presence across different regions.

  • Ian Paisley DUP North Antrim

    Recognised the contribution of British Jews to all aspects of society including politics, with mentions of figures from various political backgrounds.

  • Christine Jardine LD Edinburgh West

    Stressed that the contributions made by British Jews are often overlooked. Highlighted efforts in her constituency and elsewhere to recognise Jewish heritage and historical contributions.

  • Charlotte Nichols Lab Warrington North

    Emphasised the broad spectrum of Jewish contribution, including sports figures like Jewish wrestlers, highlighting the depth and breadth of their impact across various fields.

Government Response

Supported the creation of a British Jewish history month. Highlighted historical contributions by British Jews and expressed willingness to work with the community on this initiative.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy