Commons Sense

House of Commons · Ministerial Statement

Ukraine

28 November 2023 · 23 other contributors

Opened by James Heappey Con Wokingham

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

James Heappey raised concerns about ukraine in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • The situation in Ukraine remains largely unchanged since the last update.
  • Ukrainian forces continue to advance slowly, while Russia makes small advances towards Avdiivka and launches large drone strikes on Kyiv.
  • The UK supports Ukraine through various means including air defence, hardening of critical infrastructure, and a new commercial insurance facility for shipping in the Ukraine maritime corridor.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Government Statement

The situation in Ukraine remains largely unchanged since the last update. Ukrainian forces continue to advance slowly, while Russia makes small advances towards Avdiivka and launches large drone strikes on Kyiv. The UK supports Ukraine through air defence, hardening of critical infrastructure, artillery ammunition supply, maritime capabilities development, and a new commercial insurance facility for shipping in the Ukraine maritime corridor. To date, the UK has committed £4.6 billion to military support for Ukraine, trained over 52,000 soldiers since 2015, and continues to develop plans for further aid.

Other contributors (23)
  • John Healey Lab Rawmarsh and Conisbrough

    Question

    The right hon. Member questions the UK’s support for Ukraine, noting that despite statements about continued backing, there is no clear military funding or action plan announced in the autumn statement. He asks when the Government will pledge fresh military aid and publish a 2024 action plan.

    Minister reply

    The Minister assures the House of the UK's leadership role in supporting Ukraine with weapons systems and financial support. The pipeline for delivering these resources is reliable, reflecting discussions with Ukrainian leaders to understand their operational plans for next year. Once confirmed, the funding amount will be announced to Parliament.

  • Julian Lewis Con New Forest East

    Question

    The hon. Member questions why the previous £2.3 billion commitment was given twice but no clear number is provided for next year’s support.

    Minister reply

    The Minister states that he will convey to his colleagues in Government that Members on both sides of the House would be dismayed if less than £2.3 billion were given for the coming year.

  • Question

    The hon. Member asks when the Government will stop considering and start proscribing the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), which is a financer of Iran’s regime.

    Minister reply

    These are nuanced discussions, but the Minister will bring this question to colleagues in the Foreign Office.

  • Alec Shelbrooke Con Wetherby and Easingwold

    Question

    The right hon. Member welcomes comments about insurance for shipping in the Black sea to encourage grain exports from Ukraine and asks if the British Government will continue supporting these exports.

    Minister reply

    The Minister confirms that efforts are ongoing to ensure continued grain exports from Ukraine, which benefits many countries dependent on such supplies.

  • Seema Malhotra Lab Co-op Feltham and Heston

    Question

    In August 2022, the Defence Secretary’s predecessor promised a 2023 action plan for Ukraine, but it has not been published yet. Will the Minister explain why this action plan has not been published, and when there will be one for 2024?

    Minister reply

    The masterplan for Ukraine next year is the Ukrainians’ plan for next year, and we have a duty to resource their plan through straight cash in-year as well as commitment over three to five years thereafter. The UK will understand what that plan is and announce how it will be resourced.

  • Alicia Kearns Con Rutland and Stamford

    Question

    Will my right hon. Friend reassure me on the following two points: 1) as there are reports of a reduction in artillery deliveries to Ukraine, is enough getting through? 2) what are we doing to ensure our allies meet their 2% commitment to NATO?

    Minister reply

    Enough artillery is getting through based on military planning and manufacturing capacity, but the Ukrainian military plans for more resources if available. As for NATO’s 2% commitment, the UK will maintain its resolve and encourage other countries to step up before the Washington summit.

  • Richard Foord Lib Dem Honiton and Sidmouth

    Question

    Where does the Minister think industry, Ukrainians, and British service personnel should look for comfort given the silence in the autumn statement on continued UK support?

    Minister reply

    The Ukrainians know what they are getting this year and have seen the UK leading donations. The 2% commitment is maintained and there is investment in modernisation and recapitalisation of the armed forces.

  • Question

    Will the Minister assure the House that political resolve in NATO will remain strong if this campaign becomes enduring, protracted, and attritional?

    Minister reply

    NATO’s resolve is clear but its part in deterring escalation beyond Ukraine is distinct from donor support. The UK will maintain its commitment.

  • Question

    How is it possible that NATO ally Turkey has seen a more than threefold increase in exports to Russia of goods vital for Putin’s war machine? What are the Minister and our NATO allies going to do about that?

    Minister reply

    The Minister will write to the right hon. Gentleman with the details.

  • Mark Pritchard Con The Wrekin

    Question

    Is it concerning that the shadow Secretary of State has slipped into party political fighting over UK support for Ukraine?

    Minister reply

    It is a feature and strength of the UK response to be non-partisan. The right hon. Gentleman saw an opportunity through the omission in the autumn statement, but understanding the Ukrainian plan must come first.

  • Gavin Robinson DUP Belfast East

    Question

    Does the Minister have any assessment of the impact of ongoing issues in the Middle East on Iran’s support for Russia and whether that might present an opportunity for Ukraine?

    Minister reply

    It would be overoptimistic to think that raised tensions in the Middle East might lead to a reduction in Iranian support for Russia. The UK is working to reassure Ukrainians and deter escalation.

  • Question

    Is the Minister aware of western technology being sourced by Russia? Does he think we are doing enough to stop it?

    Minister reply

    There was an alarming level of content from the west in Russian systems early in the war, leading to constraints on supply chains. The sanctions regime largely constrains this but needs further work.

  • Question

    What steps can be taken to make the case across the world that the defence of Ukraine is in the global interest?

    Minister reply

    The UK has been making the case from the outset. The right moral outcome for Ukraine is its restoration as a free sovereign country, and failure there would embolden Putin.

  • Louie French Con Old Bexley and Sidcup

    Question

    With the media focusing on the Middle East, does the Minister agree that we must not neglect the ongoing suffering of Ukrainians at home and in battle?

    Minister reply

    The UK is committed to supporting Ukraine alongside other critical issues. The conflict is dynamic and requires sustained effort on all fronts.

  • Question

    What are the estimated military casualties from both sides, and what are the prospects for negotiations?

    Minister reply

    The Minister will provide an estimate of Russian casualties but acknowledges that Ukrainian casualties must also be considered. The war's outcome is not inevitable; sustained effort is needed to maintain current conditions.

  • Question

    How can we prevent Russia from financing its conflict through international trade, especially oil exports?

    Minister reply

    The UK works with international partners on diplomatic and economic fronts to counter Russian financing of the war.

  • Nia Griffith Lab Llanelli

    Question

    Can the Minister update us on recent discussions about Ukraine's recovery and reconstruction efforts?

    Minister reply

    The UK continues to support Ukraine's military, economic, and democratic resilience. The Prime Minister and other ministers regularly meet Ukrainian officials.

  • Question

    How many Ukrainian recruits will receive training in the UK?

    Minister reply

    The aim is to maintain current training levels, which are highly valued by both trainees and instructors.

  • Question

    Why do Ukrainians face delays in obtaining biometric residence permits?

    Minister reply

    Representations will be made to the Home Office to expedite permit processing.

  • Greg Smith Con Mid Buckinghamshire

    Question

    Does the Minister agree that air defences are crucial for securing grain exports? How can we assist in this regard?

    Minister reply

    Air defence systems are essential to protect Ukrainian infrastructure and ports. The UK is working globally to source necessary equipment.

  • Question

    What assurance can the Minister give that Ukrainians will have certainty about visa extensions in the UK?

    Minister reply

    The Home Office aims to provide as much certainty as possible, while avoiding permanent residency offers that could lead to brain drain from Ukraine.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Question

    What high-grade military equipment can the Minister allocate to aid Ukraine in its territorial advances?

    Minister reply

    The UK is providing substantial support, including advanced weaponry development assistance, though specific details cannot be disclosed.

Shadow Comment

John Healey

The shadow minister criticises the lack of a military funding plan or action plan for Ukraine in the autumn statement. The UK’s current £2.3 billion annual military support ends in March, while Germany has announced €8 billion for next year. He calls on the Government to pledge funding for fresh military aid and publish a 2024 action plan.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy