Simon Hinchley-Robson: Discharge from the RAF

Opened the debate

Mr Clive Efford discussed Simon Hinchley-Robson's mistreatment by the Royal Air Force in 1986 due to his sexuality. Robson, who signed up for a 22-year career but was discharged after being diagnosed with glandular fever and admitting he wanted an AIDS test, faced severe abuse including physical assaults and internal searches by the RAF’s Special Investigation Branch (SIB). The MP highlighted that Robson lost his pension and faced mental distress leading to suicidal thoughts. Efford called for a public apology from the Government, full pension compensation, and recognition of wrongdoings.

Government Response

Mr Alan Mak acknowledged that Mr Hinchley-Robson's experience in the RAF was unacceptable. He explained that section 10 of the Crown Proceedings Act 1947, which barred common law claims for compensation against the MOD until its repeal in 1987, applied at the time of Robson’s discharge. Mak noted that the European Court of Human Rights concluded discrimination against service personnel based on sexuality was illegal and directed the MOD to provide a remedy by 2008. He advised Robson to make a formal claim and highlighted recent Government initiatives like disregarding convictions for same-sex offences, automatic pardons for those affected, expanding powers for more veterans to benefit, supporting LGBT+ military personnel with resources such as an anti-bullying helpline, and ensuring zero-tolerance policies against discrimination. Mak emphasised the MOD's commitment to diversity and inclusion, stressing that all individuals deserve respect regardless of their background.