Commons Sense

House of Commons · Ministerial Statement

National Bus Strategy: England

15 March 2021 · 20 other contributors

Opened by Grant Shapps Con Welwyn Hatfield

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Grant Shapps raised concerns about national bus strategy: england in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Britain's bus services in England carry over 4 billion passengers annually.
  • Buses serve as a critical lifeline for key workers and everyday citizens during crises like the pandemic.
  • The Government plans to invest 3 billion to revitalise bus services, focusing on convenience, affordability, and environmental sustainability.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Government Statement

Britain's bus services are critical for the country, carrying over 4 billion passengers annually in England. Buses provide essential transportation for key workers and everyday citizens, making them a lifeline during times of crisis such as the pandemic. The current Government aims to revitalise bus services with £3 billion investment, focusing on improving passenger convenience, affordability, and environmental sustainability. Key measures include simpler fares, more integrated ticketing across public transport modes, enhanced accessibility for disabled passengers, and increased use of zero-emission buses. By June 2021, all local authorities will commit to either statutory enhanced partnerships or franchising arrangements with bus operators, leading to the creation of Bus Service Improvement Plans by October 2021. The strategy also outlines a roadmap towards a zero-emission bus fleet, aiming for 4,000 zero-emission buses and ending sales of new diesel buses.

Other contributors (20)
  • Jim McMahon Lab Oldham West and Royton

    Question

    The Labour shadow asks how the Government will ensure that the new investment reverses the cuts in bus services, restores lost routes, and brings fares down to a reasonable level for passengers. He also questions why it has taken over a year since the initial promise of 4,000 zero-emission buses before any progress is made.

    Minister reply

    Grant Shapps responds that the Government's £3 billion investment aims to revitalise bus services by improving frequency and accessibility, addressing environmental concerns, and supporting operators through partnerships. He acknowledges past challenges but asserts that the new strategy will deliver on its promises.

  • Jim McMahon Lab/Co-op Oldham West and Royton

    Question

    The shadow criticises the bus strategy as lacking ambition, not addressing cuts in services and rising prices since 2010, failing to deliver on zero-emission buses, and raising concerns about council budget black holes. He asks how many lost routes will be restored, what will be done to lower fares, and why municipal bus companies are not revisited.

    Minister reply

    The Secretary of State defends the strategy as ambitious and highlights its goal to make buses more affordable, reliable, and greener by investing £3 billion. He confirms plans for 4,000 electric buses by the end of this Parliament with an initial investment of £120 million. The Minister also mentions creative ideas like local university-run bus companies as part of a flexible approach.

  • Question

    Welcoming the bus strategy, the MP asks how best practices can be made standard and what additional investment can be given to local authorities for establishing a buses champion in each transport authority.

    Minister reply

    The Minister acknowledges the need for MPs to work with their local authorities on shaping the plan. He mentions £25 million funding by 31 October, expecting every local authority to participate and encouraging Members like Huw Merriman to lead initiatives in their areas.

  • Gavin Newlands SNP Paisley and Renfrewshire North

    Question

    Welcomes the statement on bus services but criticises the lack of urgency in implementing the strategy, questions why no zero-emission buses have been delivered outside London or Scotland since last spring, asks about commitment to 4,000 green buses and if funding will be Barnettised.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges the importance of working together for UK-wide progress, mentions hydrogen dustcarts in Glasgow as an example of collaboration. Confirms that the Barnett formula applies to this strategy.

  • Imran Ahmad Khan Lab Moss Side

    Question

    Welcomes the new bus strategy and asks about steps to unify bus franchises in West Yorkshire, specifically for Wakefield.

    Minister reply

    Commits to an integrated, London-style bus system and mentions that local authorities must create plans for multi-use tickets.

  • Sarah Olney Lib Dem Richmond Park

    Question

    Welcomes the release of 'Bus Back Better' but questions why only a review of part of the Bus Services Act 2017 is committed to, rather than scrapping those provisions entirely.

    Minister reply

    States that he does not mind who runs bus services as long as they deliver efficient and effective service.

  • Matt Western Lab Warwick and Leamington

    Question

    Expresses concern over the loss of 1,000 jobs in the UK bus and coach industry and questions why it has taken so long to introduce this plan.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges the technological challenges with zero-carbon buses but mentions upcoming zero-carbon city announcements.

  • Neil Hudson Con Epping Forest

    Question

    Welcomes the bus strategy and asks about Cumbria County Council's use of Government funds to improve rural services.

    Minister reply

    Announces £20 million for rural bus services, with Cumbria receiving £1.5 million.

  • Lloyd Russell-Moyle LD Brighton Kemptown

    Question

    Welcomes the strategy and asks about cross-border services and through pricing between authorities.

    Minister reply

    Commits to paying special attention to ensuring smooth transitions between local authority areas.

  • James Daly Con Heywood and Middleton

    Question

    Welcomes the announcement and asks if Bury Council, Transport for Greater Manchester, and bus operators will have access to further moneys and support under this strategy.

    Minister reply

    Confirms that the strategy supports high-quality bus services in outlying areas like Ramsbottom.

  • Clive Betts Lab Sheffield South East

    Question

    Welcomes aspects of the statement and asks about removing time-consuming barriers to franchising and ensuring local transport authorities receive funding for local priorities.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges suggestions but prioritises speed during the crisis, committing to more work on these points.

  • Question

    I welcome the steps outlined in the bus strategy to help operators and local authorities deliver frequent, more reliable, easier-to-use services. More comprehensive bus services will be needed, especially in rural areas such as East Devon, to protect both socially necessary and economically necessary routes and services. What plans does my right hon. Friend have to help people get the bus to work any time of day?

    Minister reply

    My hon. Friend is right to point out that, particularly in rural areas such as East Devon and in many other parts of the country, the social value of a route is often missed by the current formulas. That is one reason why, with this bus strategy, we have launched a £20 million fund to develop rural services that work better.

  • Question

    As the Member of Parliament whose constituency includes the Wrightbus factory, which has carried out pioneering work—it was the first to produce the hydrogen bus for the UK and the battery diesel bus—I have been pushing the Prime Minister on this for some time. I welcome the statement and the plans to buy British-made buses, but there are many shovel-ready projects available for zero-emission buses across the UK. Under the current plans, the roll-out will not be until 2022? What are we waiting for? Why cannot we get on with it?

    Minister reply

    I share the hon. Gentleman’s impatience, but the money is for this year. That £120 million for those zero-carbon buses is to be spent on the introduction of those first buses for this year.

  • Richard Holden Con Basildon and Billericay

    Question

    I warmly welcome the national bus strategy as another key spoke of the levelling up agenda alongside lifelong learning, the levelling-up fund and transport more generally. This is really about delivery, not dogma, and I am glad to see the options available for local authorities as well as the integrated and social nature of some of the funding available. Will the Secretary of State assure me that he will look at services in places in my constituency such as Burnhope and Weardale, which really need extra bus services later in the evenings, for potential pilot schemes?

    Minister reply

    One of the biggest points about buses is that people want to be able to get them in the evening and at the weekend. When people go somewhere to meet with somebody—those days will come again—buses should not just stop so they cannot get a bus home.

  • Stephanie Peacock Lab Barnsley South

    Question

    Spending on bus services in London is £60 higher per person than it is in South Yorkshire, where we have seen funding fall by 40% in the last decade. Any strategy is welcome, but what we really need is investment. What funding can our region expect and by when?

    Minister reply

    The hon. Lady is absolutely right. That is almost the fundamental point of the strategy. We recognise that London gets fantastic bus services, and we want the rest of the country to get some of it as well. The share is of £3 billion.

  • Question

    I am hugely excited about the opportunities that today’s announcement bring. However, when I have previously shared initiatives from the Department for Transport, the comments page underneath has said something along the lines of, “I’d settle for a bus from Hesketh Bank to Tarleton.” Will the Secretary of State give me and the people of South Ribble the confidence that communities, businesses, educational establishments and industry will be able to input their needs to transform Lancashire’s bus services?

    Minister reply

    That is absolutely right. I will say how I want this to work. I want Members in this House to have real input into it.

  • Emma Lewell Lab South Shields

    Question

    The north-east has suffered from under-investment in transport for too long. In 2019, it was revealed that over £3,600 of spend was planned per head for London and just over £500 per head for the north-east. The Prime Minister has said the strategy is an act of levelling up, but we know that phrase is a smokescreen for gifting money to areas that do not need it but happen to have a Tory MP. Will the Secretary of State tell us what criteria will be applied to ensure that this £3 billion is shared fairly among our regions?

    Minister reply

    First of all, I agree, and I just said, that London has been getting a very nice bite of the cherry with its buses, and we want the rest of the country to get the same.

  • Question

    Many rural communities rely on bus services provided by small, often family-run businesses such as Stanley Travel in my constituency, who have found it hard during covid because they do not have the resource to capital that some larger companies have. What specific help will be available to such companies to ensure that they not only survive but that those important local bus services continue?

    Minister reply

    The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right. As ever with the coronavirus, those small companies have had a tough time. It is worth mentioning that we put £240 million, and then £27 million a week, into supporting buses.

  • James Wild Con North West Norfolk

    Question

    Buses provide a lifeline for people in North West Norfolk, but rural areas have seen greater reductions in services. Will my right hon. Friend ensure that Norfolk gets a fair share of this welcome new funding to not only rebuild but enhance services, with later buses and new links, as well as capital for improvements to speed up journeys alongside the coast?

    Minister reply

    Yes I will. I have no doubt that my hon. Friend will fight for his constituents and his area.

Shadow Comment

Jim McMahon

The Labour Party criticises the Government's National Bus Strategy as lacking ambition. Despite its aim to improve bus services, it fails to address cuts in routes and services over the past decade. Since 2010, passenger journeys have fallen yearly outside of London, with 3,000 local authority-supported bus services cut. The strategy falls short on making fares more affordable for passengers and delivering a rapid transition to zero-emission buses as promised by the Prime Minister over a year ago. Labour calls for immediate measures to reverse these cuts and improve fare affordability while supporting the extension of London-style franchise powers across the country.

Get updates like this by email
▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy