Commons Sense

House of Commons · Adjournment Debate

Public Statues

25 September 2020 · 0 other contributors

Opened by David Amess Con Southend West

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

David Amess raised concerns about public statues in the House of Commons. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Statues are essential for educating about history, culture, and heritage but have become controversial due to protests against figures with controversial backgrounds.
  • Sir David Amess proposed statues for Queen Elizabeth II, Raoul Wallenberg, Eric Cole, and Dame Vera Lynn, emphasizing the need for diversity in public statues.
  • The Minister supported retaining statues and providing context through innovative methods like talking statues to explain contested figures.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

David Amess Con Southend West

Statues are essential to educate us about history, culture, and heritage. They commemorate influential individuals and events from various walks of life. However, statues have recently been a focal point of controversy, especially during the coronavirus pandemic due to protests against historical figures with controversial backgrounds. The speech emphasised that removing statues should be done through proper channels and not through illegal means. Sir David supported the proposal for a statue of Queen Elizabeth II for her platinum jubilee and highlighted his efforts in securing statues for Raoul Wallenberg and Eric Cole. He also proposed a statue for Dame Vera Lynn, recognising her significant contributions during World War II. The speech addressed the need to improve diversity in public statues, highlighting that only 80 named women are represented among the numerous statues of men.

Government Response

The Minister praised Sir David Amess for raising an important issue and highlighted the complexity surrounding the removal or erection of public statues. He emphasised that history shapes us, and erasing parts of our heritage could harm our understanding of it. The Government supports retaining and explaining statues rather than removing them. Innovative approaches such as talking statues were mentioned to provide context around contested figures. Minister Warman also expressed support for the proposed statues of Queen Elizabeth II and Dame Vera Lynn. He condemned recent protests that defaced statues, highlighting the importance of respecting memorials. The Minister concluded by expressing hope for dialogue and improved contextualisation of historical figures.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy