Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Covid-19: Strategy

11 May 2020 · 43 other contributors

Opened by Boris Johnson Con 15:31:00

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Boris Johnson raised concerns about covid-19: strategy in the House of Commons. Other MPs contributed to the debate.

Key points

  • The Prime Minister outlined a cautious plan to gradually ease lockdown measures while protecting the NHS and reducing infection rates.
  • Different regions may have varying restrictions based on local data and circumstances.
  • The phased reopening includes allowing people to return to work with social distancing, increasing fines for rule breakers, and supporting vulnerable individuals by asking them to continue shielding.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Boris Johnson Con 15:31:00

The Prime Minister outlined a cautious plan to gradually ease lockdown measures while maintaining public health safety. He emphasised the need to protect the NHS, reduce infection rates, ensure testing capacity, and avoid a second peak. Boris Johnson highlighted that different regions may have varying restrictions based on data and local circumstances. The first step involves allowing people to return to work where possible with social distancing measures, encouraging outdoor activities while maintaining caution in enclosed spaces, increasing fines for those who break rules, and supporting vulnerable individuals by asking them to continue shielding. He also mentioned the phased reopening of schools starting from primary level pupils before summer break if data supports it.

Other contributors (43)
  • Lindsay Hoyle Chorley

    The Speaker interrupted Boris Johnson's statement, requesting him to conclude within a specified timeframe.

  • Boris Johnson Con Uxbridge and South Ruislip

    The Prime Minister acknowledges the complexities in moving from a strict 'Stay at home' advice to more nuanced guidance. He emphasises that people should stay at home if they can, but go to work if their job does not allow for working from home. The reproduction rate of the disease is now between 0.5 and 0.9, allowing limited steps towards easing restrictions. Guidelines for places of employment will be published tonight, with transport guidelines out tomorrow.

  • Andrew Rosindell Con Romford

    The MP thanks the Prime Minister for his leadership during challenging times and asks him to outline a post-Brexit and post-covid economic plan. He suggests prioritising plans to boost domestic output in manufacturing and agriculture, reducing reliance on imports, supporting British business growth, and job creation.

  • Ian Blackford SNP Ross, Skye and Lochaber

    Expressed concern over the confusion caused by recent changes in government messaging regarding coronavirus restrictions. Called for clarity from the Prime Minister on several points including the new slogan, quarantine measures following travel, adherence to public health advice in devolved nations.

  • Boris Johnson Con Uxbridge and South Ruislip

    Defended the government's approach to handling the coronavirus crisis, emphasising the difference from the 2008 financial crisis. He highlighted the support provided through the furlough scheme for low-income workers and businesses in retail and hospitality sectors. Reiterated commitment to uniting and levelling up across the country.

  • Kevin Hollinrake Con Thirsk and Malton

    Welcomed the Prime Minister's statement on starting to reopen the economy while controlling virus spread, stressing the importance of rapid turnaround times for testing.

  • Edward Davey Lib Dem Kingston and Surbiton

    Asked the Prime Minister to confirm that the chief medical officer and chief scientific adviser signed off on the shift in public health message from 'Stay at home' to 'Stay alert'.

  • Mike Wood Con Kingswinford and South Staffordshire

    Suggested looking into tapering job support rather than withdrawing it overnight, proposing more flexibility such as the ability to re-furlough for a week at a time.

  • Liz Saville-Roberts PC Dwyfor Meirionnydd

    Questioned whether the Prime Minister is acting solely as the Prime Minister of England, given the three-nations approach adopted by Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.

  • Alicia Kearns Con Rutland and Stamford

    Asked for confirmation on the fine structure for those flouting rules and requested a greater deterrent to serve as a reminder that danger from the virus has not yet passed.

  • Ian Paisley Jnr DUP North Antrim

    Inquired about careful management of the economy off the job retention scheme, specifically for hospitality and tourism sectors in Northern Ireland facing potential redundancy.

  • Henry Smith Con Crawley

    Asked for more support details for the aviation sector critical to Crawley's economy, which faces significant impacts due to the crisis.

  • Chi Onwurah Lab Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West

    Expressed concern over high coronavirus infection rates in deprived areas of Newcastle and questioned whether everyone has a duty and right to stay safe as Prime Minister is asking people back to work.

  • Michael Fabricant Con L Mid Derbyshire

    Asked for clarity on what changes the Prime Minister envisions post-covid, expressing hope for a cleaner and more sustainable future.

  • Jeremy Corbyn Ind Islington North

    Critiqued the Prime Minister's statement as exacerbating inequalities and potentially worsening the situation for vulnerable groups without proper safety measures in place.

  • Alexander Stafford Con Rother Valley

    Complimented the Government's approach, asking if it is flexible enough to reopen different businesses at different times based on local conditions and public health needs.

  • Drew Hendry SNP Inverness N & Highland East

    Asked for assurance that reports of plans to cut furlough support were not true, expressing concern about potential negative impacts on public health.

  • Andy Carter Lab Guisborough

    Inquired about the Government's guidance for parents needing childcare as schools remain closed while restrictions ease.

  • Catherine McKinnell Lab Newcastle upon Tyne North

    Questioned the wisdom of easing lockdown when daily deaths persist and testing/tracing is inadequate, urging caution to avoid more fatalities.

  • Martin Vickers Con Brigg and Immingham

    Asked for assurance regarding continuing support for small businesses like guest houses and restaurants in seaside resorts as restrictions ease.

  • Mary Robinson Lab Cheadle

    Requested clarity on the easing of lockdown measures for Greater Manchester given its high R rate, stressing the importance of increased testing/tracing efforts.

  • Karen Buck Lab Stockton South

    Asked if face coverings should be mandatory on public transport to ensure safe return to work and maintain public health during easing restrictions.

  • Luke Evans Con Hinckley and Bosworth

    Asked what steps the Government will take to expedite loan applications for small businesses through schemes like Bounce-Back Loans and CBILS.

  • Chris Stephens SNP Glasgow Cathcart

    Asked the Prime Minister to recognise and reward civil servants who are processing payments during the pandemic.

  • Robert Courts Con West Oxfordshire

    Inquired about the new testing and tracing systems, asking if they will be able to detect local flare-ups of the virus.

  • Ruth Jones Lab Newport West and Islwyn

    Critiqued the Prime Minister's communication with devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland over his new plan stages.

  • Kate Green Lab/Co-op Stretford and Urmston

    Asked if there is no intention of changing rules on benefits conditionality which could pressure people to attend unsafe workplaces.

  • Robert Halfon Con Southend West

    Called for a catch-up premium and a national education volunteer force to support vulnerable pupils who missed schooling during the lockdown.

  • James Murray Lab/Co-op Ealing North

    Asked if the Prime Minister will instruct site managers to stagger their operating times in construction sites near tube stations to reduce pressure on public transport.

  • Fay Jones Con Brecon and Radnorshire

    Inquired about travel restrictions and second home usage due to differing R numbers across the country under the new changes announced by the Prime Minister.

  • Laurence Robertson Con Tewkesbury

    Shared his personal loss from the pandemic and asked the Prime Minister to take similar steps for hospital-based virus transmission as he does for community spread.

  • Daisy Cooper LDem St Albans

    Asked the Prime Minister to report openly on how numbers of PPE, tests, and temporary hospitals compare with what is actually needed in tackling the virus.

  • Edward Leigh Con Gainsborough

    Inquired about public accounts controls for increased public sector spending due to the pandemic and urged for social distancing encouragement where possible.

  • Maria Eagle Lab Liverpool Garston

    Asked if Liverpool City Council and Knowsley Borough Council will receive full reimbursement costs for their efforts during the outbreak, as initially promised.

  • Boris Johnson Con Westminster North

    The Prime Minister emphasised the government's £3.2 billion investment in local councils and clarified that 'stay alert' means encouraging those who cannot work from home to do so safely, while observing social distancing rules.

  • Chris Law SNP Dundee Central

    Questioned the Prime Minister about conflicting statements regarding travel and meeting others during the 'stay alert' phase, asking for clarity on what measures are expected to keep families safe.

  • Boris Johnson Con Westminster North

    Reiterated that 'staying alert' means people should go to work if they cannot work from home, provided their workplaces adhere to strict social distancing and safety measures.

  • Jane Hunt Con South Holland and The Deepings

    Asked the Prime Minister for assistance in allowing universities like Loughborough University to bring back students for essential training and study sessions while maintaining social distancing protocols.

  • Boris Johnson Con Westminster North

    Agreed to work with universities, including Loughborough, to ensure they can safely operate within the guidelines of social distancing and safety measures.

  • Bill Esterson Lab Sefton Central

    Expressed concerns from workers about returning to work without clear guidelines and questioned how the government will enforce these rules and provide a way for workers to voice their safety concerns.

  • Boris Johnson Con Westminster North

    Stressed the importance of making calibrated changes while respecting scientific advice, encouraging those who must return to work to do so safely under strict social distancing rules and with further guidance being published soon.

  • Peter Aldous Constitutional Conservative Waveney

    Asked for assurances that the government will address concerns about reopening primary schools, particularly regarding safety measures in classrooms and at school gates.

  • Boris Johnson Con Westminster North

    Confirmed the conditional plan to reopen primary schools on 1 June if conditions allow, based on scientific guidance, while publishing new guidelines for ensuring safe operation of schools.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy