Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Covid-19 Update

05 May 2020 · 48 other contributors

Opened by Jon Ashworth Lab Derby South

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Jon Ashworth raised concerns about covid-19 update in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Concerns were raised about the effectiveness of the Government's approach to the coronavirus, particularly in testing and tracing, protection of NHS workers, and support for deprived communities.
  • The Minister provided updates on improvements in PPE supply and addressed concerns about deaths in care homes.
  • The Minister stated that the Government's agenda to 'level up' inequalities remains a priority.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Jon Ashworth Lab Derby South

Called for a statement on the Government’s response to the coronavirus and questioned the effectiveness of their approach, particularly in relation to testing and tracing, protection of NHS workers, and support for deprived communities.

Other contributors (48)
  • Matthew Hancock Con Chichester

    Reported on the expansion of testing capacity, the resilience built up in the NHS, including Nightingale hospitals, and acknowledged the need to protect vulnerable groups such as care home residents. He also addressed concerns about PPE shortages, deaths in care homes, and non-covid healthcare needs.

  • Jon Ashworth Lab Derby South

    Asked questions regarding fair pay for NHS staff, mental health support, access to personal protective equipment, the impact of inequalities on mortality rates, testing at ports of entry, and resources available for non-covid healthcare needs.

  • Peter Bottomley Con Worthing West

    Suggested ways to make home visits safer for NHS staff by using vehicles like black cabs that can be easily cleaned and have a barrier between the driver and clinician.

  • Philippa Whitford SNP Central Ayrshire

    Discussed the effectiveness of full PPE in protecting healthcare workers from coronavirus, questioned why gowns were not included in stockpiles earlier as advised by scientific groups like NERVTAG.

  • Miriam Cates Con Spelthorne

    Acknowledged the success of increasing critical care bed capacity and the fact that some Nightingale hospitals are now not taking more patients, which he sees as a testament to the effectiveness of their approach.

  • Yvette Cooper Lab Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley

    [Inaudible.]

  • Stuart Anderson Con South Shropshire

    Asked about the plans to ensure that promised PPE deliveries arrive consistently.

  • Vicky Foxcroft Lab Lewisham North

    Expressed concern over disabled people's access to appropriate and affordable PPE for personal carers. She highlighted issues with inflated prices due to shortages.

  • David Johnston 12:30:00

    Asked about media reports suggesting that elderly individuals would be forced to stay in their homes indefinitely, seeking clarification on the government's policy regarding social distancing rules for different groups.

  • Ruth Cadbury Lab Brentford and Isleworth

    Inquired about the Government’s plans for immediate and long-term mental health treatment for those affected by the emotional impact of the virus, especially frontline workers who are often reluctant to seek help.

  • Dean Russell 12:30:00

    Confirmed that everyone on the frontline will have full support from the Government as Watford volunteers see first-hand the inspirational work done by various roles in fighting against coronavirus.

  • Munira Wilson Lib Dem Twickenham

    Raised issues regarding testing availability, prioritisation at local sites, and loss of tests, seeking assurances on when the UK would have sufficient testing capacity to implement a test, trace, and isolate strategy.

  • Luke Evans Con Hinckley and Bosworth

    Asked for clarity on definitions and entitlements for different vulnerable groups as lockdown measures are considered for easing.

  • Caroline Lucas 12:30:00

    Inquired about the role of public health professionals in community tracing efforts, expressing concern over potential outsourcing to private companies which have not proven effective.

  • Matthew Hancock Con South Basildon and East Thurrock

    Defends the role of private sector partners in the test, track and trace programme, emphasises the importance of collaboration between public and private sectors. Acknowledges the Mayor of London's need to provide more tube trains for safer public transport. Supports cancer treatments resuming as safely possible when advised by clinicians. Reiterates that the NHS has not been overwhelmed at any point during the crisis. Defends the Government's response, stating they have achieved their priority goal of preventing the NHS from being overtopped. Urges constituents to follow clear guidance on shielding set out on the NHS website. Acknowledges challenges in providing new government guidance for visually impaired individuals and directs them to primary care. Highlights that 80% of Isle of Wight residents are willing to download the NHS app, which is part of a system designed to account for those without smartphones.

  • Felicity Buchan Con Crawley

    Asks if the Mayor of London needs to provide more tube trains to ensure safer public transport in order to get London back to work.

  • Ben Lake PC Ceredigion Preseli

    Suggests that the Secretary of State should consider community testing and contact tracing systems being developed by local councils and health boards, which could offer local solutions complementary to any UK-wide infrastructure.

  • Nigel Mills Con Amber Valley

    Requests assurance for constituents who are nervous about resuming cancer treatments due to fear of catching coronavirus at the hospital.

  • Catherine McKinnell Lab Newcastle upon Tyne North

    Critiques the Government's approach, citing their own measure suggesting that deaths below 20,000 would be a success. Asks how they can claim success when the death toll has surpassed this.

  • Jack Brereton Con Stoke-on-Trent Central

    Acknowledges the magnificent response of the British people and asks for confirmation that the NHS was not overwhelmed at any point during the crisis.

  • Chris Bryant Lab Rhondda and Ogmore

    Asks about the clarity of Government advice to over-70-year-olds on leaving their homes and inquires if face masks will be advised for public transport use.

  • Joy Morrissey Con Beaconsfield

    Inquires about provisions made for visually impaired individuals during the coronavirus pandemic.

  • Martyn Day SNP Linlithgow and East Falkirk

    Asks about the estimate of NHS app downloads required to make it effective in keeping people safe, as well as discussions on making it compulsory if not enough people download it.

  • Laura Farris Con Gedling

    Welcomes the launch of the test, track and trace app but questions its lower take-up by elderly individuals due to lack of smart phone access.

  • Abena Oppong-Asare Lab Erith and Thamesmead

    Asked the Secretary of State if there are plans to publish a report on the effects of covid-19 on people who fall under one or more protected characteristics.

  • Announced that Public Health England has launched work looking into disparities in the impact of COVID-19. Stated that evidence indicates a lesser impact on children and women compared to men, and highlighted the importance of obesity's role. Emphasised listening to scientists and medics.

  • Heather Wheeler Con Constituency unknown

    Congratulated the Secretary of State for his work and suggested placing a memorial at the National Arboretum in commemoration of essential workers who lost their lives to covid-19.

  • Kirsty Blackman SNP Aberdeen North

    Inquired about what number of daily cases must be reached for test, track and trace measures to prevent a peak if restrictions are lifted.

  • Christopher Chope Con Christchurch

    Asked the Secretary of State whether changes to lockdown should be announced in Parliament first and requested release of findings from Exercise Cygnus to prove transparency.

  • Claire Coutinho Con East Surrey

    Inquired about evidence regarding under-10s being at a lower risk for coronavirus symptoms and transmission, and asked what work is being done to explore this further.

  • Steve McCabe Lab Constituency unknown

    Asked whether the advice given to pregnant women working on frontline health and social care about safety and income was sufficiently clear and consistent.

  • Steven Baker Con Wycombe

    Acknowledged the Secretary of State's work, including delivering mobile testing in Wycombe, and asked about restoring full-scale elective surgery in NHS for non-covid conditions.

  • Alistair Carmichael Lib Dem Orkney and Shetland

    Reported issues with the test website directing residents to off-island testing centres, requesting adjustments to ensure local provision.

  • Angela Richardson Con Guildford Constituency

    Paid tribute to the Royal Surrey County Hospital and its leadership for their innovative approach during the crisis. Requested assurances of continued support and investment in diagnostics.

  • Bill Esterson Lab Sefton Central

    Asked about improving procurement processes so that companies can supply tests more easily, citing an example with Curative facing roadblocks in UK supply.

  • Desmond Swayne Con New Forest West

    Inquired about the feasibility of moving to robust personal protection equipment capable of being decontaminated multiple times for reuse.

  • Afzal Khan Lab Manchester Rusholme

    Requested suspension of NHS charging regulations for migrants due to disproportionate impact on BME communities during the pandemic, citing advice from medical organisations.

  • Theresa Villiers Con Constituency unknown

    Asked about measures in place to prevent discharges into care homes of patients with suspected or confirmed covid-19 cases to avoid spread.

  • Emphasised the strengthened rules on discharges from hospitals to care homes, noting a decrease in deaths due to coronavirus in care homes. Announced privacy measures for the tracing app and its role in test-track-and-tracing efforts, encouraging public confidence through transparency and civic duty. Addressed scheduling concerns, cross-border issues with Ireland, and provided updates on PPE procurement and dental practice reopening plans.

  • Asked about the data protection measures in place for the tracing app to ensure public confidence in its use and security.

  • Peter Bone Con Newbury

    Inquired about the proper protocol for government policy announcements, suggesting they should be made first in Parliament before going to the media.

  • Stephen Farry SF North Down

    Expressed concerns over potential operational issues arising from different contact tracing systems being used between the UK and Ireland, particularly Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.

  • Julian Lewis Con New Forest East

    Informed the Secretary of State about a firm in his constituency that could supply significant amounts of PPE if contacted by Government officials.

  • Alex Sobel Lab Co-op Leeds Central and Headingley

    Raised concerns from dentists who feel their measures are insufficient to protect them, fearing bankruptcy and closure due to the current crisis, highlighting an existential threat to NHS dentistry.

  • Maria Miller Con Basingstoke

    Inquired about steps being taken to move forward with dental practices similar to those taken for hospitals during the crisis.

  • Alyn Smith PC Na h-Eileanan an Iar

    Expressed concern over reports that the UK is not making substantial progress on reducing infection rates, asking if this data will be considered in decisions about easing lockdown.

  • Jason McCartney Con Colne Valley

    Asked for advice on getting staff at a local care home tested without having their own transportation to testing facilities.

  • Yvette Cooper Lab Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley

    Pressed the Health Secretary for evidence behind the decision not to ask people arriving from abroad to self-isolate, expressing concern that this information was not included in recent papers.

Government Response

Provided updates on PPE supply improvements, addressed concerns about deaths in care homes, and reiterated the importance of suppressing the virus. He also discussed the role of local authority public health services and stated that the Government's agenda to 'level up' inequalities remains a priority. Responded to a range of questions, including on the impact on different demographics, test procurement challenges, and issues around personal protection equipment. Announced work by Public Health England to investigate disparities in coronavirus impacts.

Get updates like this by email
▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy