Commons Sense

House of Commons · Ministerial Statement

Flybe

05 March 2020 · 30 other contributors

Opened by Kelly Tolhurst Con East Surrey

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Kelly Tolhurst raised concerns about flybe in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Flybe has ceased trading, affecting over 15,000 passengers on travel day
  • The government prioritizes supporting affected passengers and employees
  • Review of regional connectivity and air passenger duty will be conducted

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Government Statement

Flybe has ceased trading, impacting over 15,000 passengers due to travel today. The government's priority is to support affected passengers and employees. Flybe faced financial challenges due to decreased bookings and increased competition, compounded by the recent outbreak of coronavirus. The government will review regional connectivity and air passenger duty to ensure sustainable and climate-friendly solutions. Existing alternative transport options are available for passengers, including rail and road. Government representatives are available at airports to assist affected individuals. Jobcentre Plus outlets and redundancy payment services will support laid-off employees. The aviation industry is facing challenges due to coronavirus; the government stands ready to provide further support if needed.

Other contributors (30)
  • Karl Turner Lab Kingston upon Hull East

    Question

    What steps is the Minister taking to help those workers find new jobs, given the heavy reliance of many regions on aviation?

    Minister reply

    The Department for Work and Pensions stands ready with its rapid response service offer at local Jobcentre Plus outlets. Additionally, the Insolvency Service's redundancy payment scheme will ensure timely payments to affected employees from the national insurance fund.

  • Karl Turner Lab Kingston upon Hull East

    Question

    Will the Government draw on the CAA’s skills and expertise if existing capacity does not suffice for all Flybe passengers?

    Minister reply

    The Civil Aviation Authority is already playing a crucial role, and other airlines like easyJet are offering rescue fares. The government will continue to work closely with industry stakeholders to ensure safe passage of affected passengers.

  • Karl Turner Lab Kingston upon Hull East

    Question

    What assessment has the Minister made regarding the risk posed by coronavirus to other airlines, and what preparations are in place?

    Minister reply

    An ongoing review is being conducted to assess risks. The government is working closely with aviation industry representatives to ensure that necessary support measures are in place as required.

  • Karl Turner Lab Kingston upon Hull East

    Question

    Will the Minister address the industry’s concerns over slot usage rules urgently?

    Minister reply

    The government acknowledges these concerns and will discuss them further during a roundtable with aviation industry members next week.

  • Karl Turner Lab Kingston upon Hull East

    Question

    The collapse of Flybe is disastrous, resulting in 2,000 job losses. What steps are being taken to help workers find new jobs? The MP also raised concerns about regional connectivity and the need for government intervention on airline insolvency rules.

    Minister reply

    Tolhurst acknowledged the job losses and said the Government would provide support through industry initiatives, such as prioritising Flybe staff in recruitment processes. She stated that the Government has been working to maintain passenger routes and protect regional airports' viability.

  • Huw Merriman Con East Grinstead

    Question

    Airline insolvency reform was promised in the Queen's Speech. When will legislation be introduced to help airlines either unwind or recover?

    Minister reply

    Tolhurst committed to moving forward with this legislation as soon as possible and offered to provide updates.

  • Gavin Newlands SNP Paisley and Renfrewshire North

    Question

    The MP expressed concern about the impact on employees, passengers, and regional connectivity in Scotland. He asked for assurances regarding refunds for affected passengers and promised action on public service obligations.

    Minister reply

    Tolhurst assured that Loganair had committed to maintaining 16 routes and that the Department would work with industry to backfill other routes and maintain airport viability. She offered to discuss the Scottish situation further.

  • Simon Jupp Con East Devon

    Question

    The MP expressed concern about Flybe’s impact on regional connectivity in his constituency, especially at Exeter airport.

    Minister reply

    Tolhurst assured that the Department is working to secure as many routes as possible and offered support for those who have lost their jobs.

  • Angela Eagle Lab Wallasey

    Question

    Asks if the Government's inaction on infrastructure might exacerbate the economic impact of coronavirus.

    Minister reply

    Disagrees, stating that Flybe was not allowed to go bankrupt without government action and emphasises ongoing assessment of wider economic impacts.

  • Paul Holmes Con Hamble Valley

    Question

    Inquires about support for regional airports, particularly Southampton airport, in light of Flybe's collapse.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges the importance of regional connectivity and expresses commitment to working with local constituencies.

  • Karin Smyth Lab Bristol South

    Question

    Asks for a statement on support for Northern Ireland’s economy due to Flybe's impact.

    Minister reply

    Confirms that the government is working with affected areas and acknowledges the importance of connectivity in Northern Ireland.

  • Steve Double Cornwall

    Question

    Inquires about the continuation of the Newquay to London public sector obligation route.

    Minister reply

    Confirms commitment to keeping the PSO route operational and working with local officials to find a new carrier.

  • Stephen Farry Northern Ireland

    Question

    Asks for recognition of Northern Ireland's unique circumstances in response strategies.

    Minister reply

    Agrees that special considerations are necessary due to the lack of alternative road and rail links, and commits to working with regional colleagues.

  • Steve Brine Hampshire

    Question

    Discusses the impact on Hampshire’s economy and asks for government measures to support regional connectivity.

    Minister reply

    Commits to reviewing regional air connectivity and developing policies that work for local economies, focusing on short-term solutions.

  • Alex Cunningham Middlesbrough S

    Question

    Asks about the impact of Flybe's collapse on Teesside airport and operations.

    Minister reply

    Confirms discussions with the Tees Valley Mayor and commitment to working with airlines and airports to maintain viability.

  • David Duguid Berwick

    Question

    Asks for confirmation of government support to minimize disruption caused by Flybe's route loss.

    Minister reply

    Commits to working closely with industry, airports, and airlines to understand issues and challenges.

  • Alistair Carmichael Lib Dem Orkney and Shetland

    Question

    Asks the Minister to ensure regional flights are prioritised at hub airports.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges concerns about slots being taken up by larger airlines and commits ongoing conversations with airlines.

  • Caroline Nokes Con Romsey & South Hants

    Question

    Asks for commitment to prioritise Southampton airport's connectivity issues post-Flybe.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges concerns about Southampton and commits to working with colleagues, airlines, and airports to solve issues.

  • Stephen Doughty Lab Co-op Cardiff South and Penarth

    Question

    Expresses concerns about the lack of attention to routes to Northern Ireland, particularly Cardiff airport's connectivity issues. Inquires if ferry travel will be included in free rail travel or rescue fares.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges the point and assures that colleagues are working on options for ferry travel as part of support measures.

  • Saqib Bhatti Con Meriden and Solihull East

    Question

    Concerns about staff in his constituency, requests details on Department for Transport's measures to support Flybe's former employees.

    Minister reply

    Promises rapid response service from the Work and Pensions department. Loganair will prioritise hiring Flybe’s former staff.

  • Gavin Robinson DUP Belfast East

    Question

    Highlights the significance of regional connectivity to Belfast City airport and seeks assurances that the Chancellor, through air passenger duty, and other Departments will support growth in regional connectivity.

    Minister reply

    Commits to working with Northern Ireland Executive on devolution of short-haul APD.

  • Question

    Asks for collaboration between Employment Minister and the DWP to address perception of specialisation in aviation sector, making it a barrier to entry for other employers.

    Minister reply

    Agrees on recognition of transferrable skills among highly skilled individuals who have been working for Flybe.

  • Stephen Timms Lab East Ham

    Question

    Concerns about supply chain jobs at risk, requests support from the Department for Work and Pensions. Asks for reassurances regarding pension schemes of former employees based in the Isle of Man.

    Minister reply

    Promises to work across Government departments to address issues faced by staff, including lessons learned from Thomas Cook's collapse.

  • Question

    Draws parallels between Flybe and Thomas Cook collapses, inquires about measures taken to prevent future occurrences.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges challenges faced by airlines due to coronavirus but assures ongoing work with the industry.

  • Question

    Suggests that domestic flights are sometimes the only viable option and asks for commitment from the Minister on building infrastructure in certain parts of the country.

    Minister reply

    Commits to levelling up all regions, including air, rail and other forms of transport.

  • Question

    Highlights Flybe's reliance on both domestic and European flights, affected by Brexit. Inquires about evaluations of companies facing weakness due to Brexit.

    Minister reply

    Acknowledges ongoing work with industry to understand challenges faced by airlines.

  • Chi Onwurah Lab Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West

    Question

    Raises concerns about impacts on regional economies, cultural activities, and sports fans due to the absence of decent cross-country rail links.

    Minister reply

    Promises specific action to ensure people can travel for planned events.

  • Question

    Asks if British Government will remove ideological opposition to empowering Welsh Government with powers over APD, as Scotland and Northern Ireland have.

    Minister reply

    States no plans to change APD policy. Refers to Exchequer Secretary’s response on the matter.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Question

    In Northern Ireland, the significance of Belfast City airport is greater than that of other airports. Other airlines may be prepared to fill gaps left by current carriers, but there is concern about declining connectivity in the UK and calls for urgent action on Air Passenger Duty (APD).

    Minister reply

    The Government will work closely with airports and airlines serving Northern Ireland to maintain important connectivity between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK. The Chancellor has committed to reviewing APD, and we have outlined our manifesto commitment to delivering short-haul APD reductions in Northern Ireland.

Shadow Comment

Karl Turner

The collapse of Flybe represents a significant loss, particularly in terms of jobs and regional connectivity. The shadow minister questions the measures taken by the government to assist those affected by this crisis. He calls for a thorough assessment of the risk posed to other airlines due to coronavirus and asks about preparations made to address these risks. Additionally, he highlights the importance of maintaining vital regional links following Flybe's collapse and urges the government to urgently review industry concerns over slot usage rules that may force inefficient flight operations.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy