Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Exiting the European Union

09 January 2020 · 55 other contributors

Opened by Andy Carter Con Q1

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Andy Carter raised concerns about exiting the european union in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Government plans to commemorate the UK's exit from the EU on 31 January 2020 were discussed.
  • The Minister mentioned proposals for celebrating the event, including special beers and flying Union flags.
  • Measures such as a 9 million fund to support outreach groups and charities for small businesses and non-UK EU nationals were highlighted.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Andy Carter Con Q1

Asked about Government plans to commemorate and celebrate the UK leaving the EU on 31 January 2020.

Other contributors (55)
  • Kate Griffiths Con Q11

    Proposed that local breweries in Burton-on-Trent should brew a celebratory Brexit beer to mark the occasion.

  • Mark Logan Con Q17

    Suggested commemorating the day of constitutional importance annually as an anniversary.

  • Emphasised that 31 January is significant for Eurosceptics across Europe and advocated for public celebrations to signal life outside the EU.

  • Hilary Benn Lab Leeds South

    Asked if the Government’s plans include abolishing the Department for Exiting the European Union after exit day, questioning which Minister will take responsibility for negotiations.

  • Barry Sheerman Independent Labour Group Haringey and Wood Green

    Noted concerns raised by the President of the European Commission regarding free movement of labour impacting trade agreements post-Brexit.

  • Patrick Grady Lab Garscadden and Sighthill

    Asked if Big Ben will chime to mark 11 pm on January 31, expressing concern that it may not be a moment of celebration for many.

  • Daniel Zeichner Lab Cambridge

    Urged the Government to adopt a careful tone and inquired about measures for non-UK EU nationals who feel vulnerable post-Brexit.

  • John Hayes Con South Holland and The Deepings

    Suggested flying Union flags from public buildings as a tribute to the decision made by British people to leave the European Union.

  • Tim Farron Lib Dem Westmorland and Lonsdale

    Asked how Brexit can be depicted without appearing insular or nationalistic, suggesting signing up for refugee resettlement schemes as a way to counter this perception.

  • Mohammad Yasin Lab Bedford

    Since October, the withdrawal agreement Bill has undergone major changes, including the stripping out of previous commitments to workers’ rights. Will the Secretary of State publish a revised impact assessment so that he can be honest with the public about what his Government have in store for them with their hard Brexit plan?

  • Liz Twist Lab Blaydon and Consett

    So far, the Prime Minister has taken workplace rights out of the withdrawal agreement in October and the withdrawal agreement Bill in December. What confidence can we have that workplace rights will be protected under this Government?

  • Does the Secretary of State agree that, contrary to what the hon. Member for Bedford (Mohammad Yasin) said, we need dynamic alignment like a hole in the head? The purpose of Brexit is to enable us to make our own laws and rules, set our own taxes and chart our own course.

  • I thank the Secretary of State for his answer on dynamic alignment. As his Department winds up, I thank him personally for leading it with such professionalism, and I thank his team at DExEU. On dynamic alignment, I ask my right hon. Friend to reflect on the fact that the Brexit vote was about this House being sovereign.

  • Nick Thomas-Symonds Lab Torfaen

    Will the Secretary of State give an absolute guarantee that post Brexit, under a Conservative Government, there will never be a point at which workers in the EU27 enjoy stronger employment rights than they do here? A Government genuinely committed to workers’ rights would have given a straight yes to that question, but the Secretary of State did not.

  • What recent discussions he has had with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on maintaining environmental standards after the UK leaves the EU. It is vital that we not only maintain but enhance our environmental protections, and that we enhance our natural environment.

  • What recent discussions he has had with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on maintaining environmental standards after the UK leaves the EU. The United Kingdom has some of the highest food standards, so will my right hon. Friend confirm that Her Majesty’s Government will not allow substandard agricultural or food imports after the UK leaves the EU.

  • The Secretary of State will know that the EU’s groundbreaking European green deal includes many policies with which UK alignment will be straightforward. Others will be more challenging. For example, the circular economy action plan will seek to change business models and set minimum standards for producers.

  • Whether the UK will be required to comply with (a) EU law and (b) rulings of the European Court of Justice after the UK leaves the EU.

  • Lia Nici Con Great Grimsby

    Emphasised that her constituency and coastal areas voted to take back control of fishing laws post-Brexit, stressing its importance.

  • Huw Merriman Con Bexhill and Battle

    Asked about the ECJ's role in determining issues arising under the withdrawal agreement, concerned about disputes resolution mechanism.

  • Chris Clarkson Lab Preston North

    Acknowledged that his constituents voted for Brexit to take back control of laws and be free from Brussels’ influence.

  • Kieran Mullan Con Bexhill and Battle

    Asked about discussions on the effect of UK leaving EU on NHS, highlighted concerns over continued flow of medicines post-Brexit.

  • Philippa Whitford SNP Central Ayrshire

    Critiqued anti-immigrant rhetoric, pointed out a decline in EU nurses and questioned the Prime Minister's commitment to NHS funding promises.

  • Brendan Clarke-Smith Con Bassetlaw

    Asked about additional funding for NHS post-Brexit, welcomed new funding assurances.

  • Philip Dunne Constitutional Democratic Unionist Party Wells

    Inquired about discussions on EU spouse fees and raised concerns over application costs preventing long-term residents from applying for citizenship.

  • Expressed moral objection to high fees charged to EU citizens who wish to remain in the UK post-Brexit.

  • Philip Hollobone Con Kettering

    Asked about comparability of EU27 settlement schemes with those of the UK, highlighted importance of mutual agreements on fees and charges.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Inquired about intentions to equalise immigration fees for European and Commonwealth partners to ensure fairness.

  • Joy Morrissey Con Beaconsfield

    Sought assurance on no charge for EU citizens applying for settled status in the UK post-Brexit.

  • Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem Bath

    Asked about discussions with Cabinet colleagues on protecting rights of EU citizens and expressed concerns over future Windrush-like situations.

  • The fact that 3.5 million EU citizens see the best future for themselves and their families as to remain living and working in post-Brexit Britain is a huge endorsement of our post-Brexit prospects, according to him.

  • Steve Barclay Con North East Cambridgeshire

    He urged Members on both sides of the House to support Third Reading of the withdrawal agreement Bill because it safeguards the rights of EU citizens and UK citizens in Europe. He also discussed ongoing conversations with ministerial colleagues on exiting the European Union, including agricultural policy.

  • She questioned how the Secretary of State believed that refusing to provide paper proof of status, rejecting Labour’s proposal for automatic status, and granting pre-settled status to people who have been here legally felt valued and welcome.

  • Kevin Hollinrake Con Thirsk and Malton

    He inquired about discussions with Cabinet colleagues on potential opportunities for farmers and the agricultural sector after Brexit, as well as assurance that future free trade agreements would only allow tariff-free imports from producers observing high standards.

  • Mel Stride Con Central Devon

    He congratulated Steve Barclay on his service and urged him to liaise closely with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to ensure an excellent deal for hill farmers.

  • Kerry McCarthy Lab Bristol East

    She expressed concerns about the lack of trust from farmers regarding government assurances and requested specific measures to ensure no lowering of standards in future trade deals.

  • Gregory Campbell DUP East Londonderry

    He sought assurance that his departmental and Cabinet colleagues were aware of the importance of the agri-food sector in Northern Ireland and would minimise threats while maximising opportunities as they left the EU.

  • Andrew Bowie Con West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine

    He highlighted the importance of the food and drink sector to Scotland's economy, particularly in relation to Scottish whisky and salmon.

  • He emphasised that a no-deal crash-out would be disastrous for both sectors and stressed the need for statutory roles for the Scottish Government in future relationships with the EU and trade deals negotiated by the UK.

  • He asked whether the Government would introduce any changes to the seasonal agricultural workers scheme after the UK leaves the EU, given the importance of such workers for farmers in his constituency.

  • Chris Bryant Lab Rhondda and Ogmore

    He expressed concerns about Welsh hill farmers being among the most exposed if there was a no-deal Brexit at the end of the year, urging the Secretary of State to ensure that any deal signed off on would guarantee tariff-free access for lamb into the European Union.

  • Asked about recent discussions with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on fishing and marine policy after the UK leaves the EU.

  • Steve Barclay Con North East Cambridgeshire

    Welcomed Karl McCartney back to his place and confirmed ongoing discussions with ministerial colleagues on all aspects of exiting the European Union, including fisheries and marine policy. Emphasised a 100% confidence in leaving the common fisheries policy and gaining full control over fishing areas and quotas.

  • Asked about the Secretary of State's agreement on close working between UK authorities and their continental equivalents, suggesting that discussions between tax authorities in the UK and France on customs processes should start.

  • Keir Starmer Lab Holborn and St Pancras

    Thanked Steve Barclay for his kind words but expressed disappointment over the Government's decision regarding unaccompanied child refugees. Urged reconsideration of this issue, highlighting moral concerns.

  • Sally-Ann Hart Lab Hastings and Rye

    Asked about specific attention to under-10 metre fishing boats in post-Brexit Britain, emphasising their importance for sustainable fishing practices.

  • Commended Sally-Ann Hart on her election and confirmed special attention would be given to the 10-metre fleet under a domestic fisheries policy that promotes traditional practices for stock protection.

  • Matt Western Lab Warwick and Leamington

    Asked about discussions regarding impacts of Brexit, specifically a hard no-deal scenario, on the movement of UK performing arts between here and Europe.

  • Christian Wakeford Con Bury South

    Congratulated Steve Barclay on ensuring that this Government will deliver on the verdict and the will of the British people to leave the EU on 31 January. Noted with the closure of DExEU, there would be a celebration of the hard work done by officials.

  • Bambos Charalambous Lab Southgate and Wood Green

    Asked whether EU citizens who work in the UK post-Brexit will be liable for the immigration health surcharge, and if similar charges will be introduced for UK citizens living in the EU.

  • Steve Barclay Con North East Cambridgeshire

    Guaranteed to all EU citizens in the UK that their rights are protected under the withdrawal agreement Bill, including healthcare rights. Called on the Labour MP to support the Bill at Third Reading.

  • Asked if the UK will remain an open place for EU citizens to study and whether Britain continues leading in higher education quality.

  • Confirmed that the Government aims to attract students from the EU and globally, citing traditions of attracting talented individuals. Mentioned support for civil servants during oral questions.

  • Asked for assurance that the European Union Aviation Safety Agency will continue as is post-Brexit, allowing Airbus to plan ahead without regulatory divergence.

  • Chris Loder Con West Dorset

    Sought steps from HM Government to ensure a fair price for farmers by redressing the imbalance in food supply chain prices following Brexit.

Government Response

Responded positively to proposals for commemorating the event in various ways, including celebratory beers and flying Union flags. Addressed concerns about small businesses and non-UK EU nationals, highlighting measures taken such as a £9 million fund to support outreach groups and charities. The hon. Lady says that as if she supported the Bill in October, but she did not. She did not support it when those things were in the clause, and now she is lamenting that they are out of the clause that she did not support... The Government have been clear that we will not weaken our current environmental protections as we leave the European Union, and that we will maintain, and even enhance, our already high environmental standards. Responded to multiple MPs addressing issues ranging from fishing laws, ECJ role post-Brexit, NHS funding, immigration fees, and EU citizens' rights. Stressed the importance of arbitration panels over the ECJ, confirmed free settlement scheme applications for EU residents, and highlighted NHS's multi-year funding settlement. Government minister's speech includes addressing concerns regarding EU citizens' rights and future trade agreements, ensuring that farmers would not lose any rights when they get pre-settled status. He also discussed ongoing conversations with ministerial colleagues on exiting the European Union. Discussed ongoing conversations about fisheries and marine policy post-Brexit. Emphasised confidence in leaving common fisheries policy and gaining full control over UK waters. Also addressed the Government's position on unaccompanied child refugees, highlighting a commitment to supporting refugees as per manifesto promises. Emphasised commitment to protecting EU citizens' rights and attracting students from the EU. Also highlighted opportunities for agriculture post-Brexit, aiming to free farmers from bureaucratic constraints through the Agriculture Bill.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy